What if the reason you struggle to trust isn’t about others—but something quietly buried in your past?
We aren’t born suspicious.
Sure, some of us might lean cautious, but deep distrust—the kind that keeps us second-guessing others’ motives and tightening our emotional drawbridge—usually doesn’t appear out of nowhere. It’s shaped over time, often subtly, by the very experiences we hoped to move past.
What’s tricky is that you might not even realize the connection. You just know it’s hard to open up, to lean on others, to let anyone really in. But when you start tracing the lines backward, you might see these patterns started much earlier than your current relationships.
Let’s explore eight formative experiences that can quietly, persistently shape how much (or how little) you trust today.
1. Growing up with unpredictable caregivers
Did your caregivers have a “mood lottery” vibe—warm one day, icy the next?
When affection and attention are inconsistent, kids learn to scan for threats instead of feeling safe. One moment you’re laughing at the dinner table, the next you’re getting the silent treatment without knowing why. Over time, that builds a baseline belief: people aren’t safe, and love can vanish without warning.
This doesn’t just disappear when you hit adulthood. You might find yourself hyper-vigilant in relationships, constantly bracing for the other shoe to drop. Or maybe you keep emotional distance, convincing yourself it’s safer not to need anyone at all.
As Rudá Iandê notes in his book Laughing in the Face of Chaos, “Being human means inevitably disappointing and hurting others, and the sooner you accept this reality, the easier it becomes to navigate life's challenges.” This hit me hard. It reminded me that no relationship is risk-free—but we don’t have to armor up forever.
2. Being betrayed by someone you trusted deeply
Whether it was a cheating partner, a lying friend, or a co-worker who threw you under the bus—betrayal changes things.
And not just in the moment. A deep betrayal rewires your nervous system. You might start assuming ulterior motives where none exist. Even kind gestures can trigger suspicion. You might tell yourself, “I’m just being cautious,” but underneath, it’s fear whispering, “Don’t fall for it again.”
I once trusted someone with a vulnerable piece of my story, and they turned it into gossip. It took years before I could speak that truth again, even to people who had earned my trust. That’s the thing about betrayal—it echoes.
But here's what I’ve learned: healing doesn’t mean forgetting. It means giving yourself permission to rebuild your boundaries, brick by careful brick, and letting new people prove they’re different.
3. Having your emotions dismissed or shamed
Did anyone ever tell you to “stop being so sensitive” or that you were “overreacting”?
When you're repeatedly told your feelings are wrong, irrational, or too much, you start to internalize the message that youare wrong. That emotional gaslighting—intentional or not—makes you question your own reality. And if you can’t trust yourself, how can you trust anyone else?
I remember sharing a fear with someone once, and their response was a quick, “You’re being dramatic.” It wasn’t meant cruelly, but the sting lingered. After that, I started editing myself, withholding anything that felt even slightly raw.
Over time, this erodes self-trust. You become overly dependent on others to interpret situations for you, or you shut down completely.
As the book Laughing in the Face of Chaos reminds us, “Our emotions are not barriers, but profound gateways to the soul.” When we treat our emotions as valid—even the messy ones—we start reclaiming that inner compass.
4. Witnessing chronic conflict or instability in early life
Even if no one yelled at you directly, just being around constant conflict—shouting matches, slammed doors, long silences—can quietly shape your nervous system.
Kids absorb emotional tension like sponges.
Research indicates that chronic and/or extreme stress in early life, often referred to as early adversity, childhood trauma, or early life stress, has been associated with a wide range of adverse effects on development.
If your early environment was full of unpredictable fights or dramatic reconciliations, your brain may have learned that connection = chaos. That’s not something you consciously decide; it’s something your body remembers.
So now, when someone tries to get close? You might instinctively withdraw. Or test them. Or pick fights just to feel in control of the narrative.
This isn’t about blame—it’s about awareness. Understanding this connection gives you the chance to say, “Okay, I see where this started. I don’t have to keep reliving it.”
And honestly? That realization alone can be a turning point.
5. Being the “responsible one” too early
Were you the kid who packed your own lunches, comforted your parents, or made sure your siblings got out the door on time?
When children are placed in adult roles too soon, it creates a skewed relationship with trust. You learn that no one is really looking out for you, so you have to handle everything yourself. That hyper-independence might have been necessary back then—but it’s lonely in the long run.
As adults, people who had to grow up too fast often struggle to delegate, ask for help, or let themselves lean on others without guilt. Trusting someone else to take the wheel feels risky, even reckless.
But here’s the truth: independence isn’t the same as wholeness. As Rudá Iandê puts it, “The greatest gift we can give to ourselves and to each other is the gift of our own wholeness.” Letting yourself be supported is part of that wholeness. You don’t have to do it all, all the time.
6. Being judged for your vulnerability
Maybe you opened up once—and someone used it against you.
Maybe they mocked your feelings. Or brushed them off. Or shared your story with someone else.
That kind of experience doesn’t just sting—it teaches your nervous system a dangerous lesson: vulnerability = danger. So you shut down, stop sharing, or only offer the most polished version of yourself. Over time, you might even convince yourself you’re just “private” or “self-reliant,” when really, you’re still protecting a very old wound.
A 2024 study in Personal Relationships found that individuals with higher levels of attachment avoidance tend to share selectively—often only positive events—and avoid disclosing vulnerabilities, as a way to protect themselves from emotional risk.
But here’s what I’ve found: true connection only happens when we risk being seen. Not just the good stuff—but the awkward, scared, uncertain parts too. As scary as it feels, letting someone see the real you is also how you discover who’s truly safe to trust.
Start small. Share a little. Then see what they do with it.
7. Experiencing manipulation or emotional control
If someone in your past twisted your words, guilt-tripped you, or made you question your memories—there’s a good chance you developed what psychologists call “trust trauma.”
You start scanning conversations for hidden meanings. You look for signs you’re being played. You worry that being open gives someone too much leverage.
This doesn’t just affect romantic relationships—it can creep into friendships, work dynamics, even family conversations. I’ve worked with people who second-guess every compliment because deep down, they fear a hidden agenda.
The challenge here is reclaiming your ability to discern. That means listening to your gut—but also learning to trust what’s in front of you, not just the ghosts of your past.
And yes, healing from emotional manipulation is hard. But it’s possible. Especially when you begin to trust yourself again.
8. Being told you’re “too much” or “not enough”
This one’s sneaky.
Maybe you were told you were too needy. Too intense. Too loud. Or maybe you were told you didn’t measure up—weren’t smart enough, mature enough, attractive enough.
These messages lodge themselves deep in your psyche. And eventually, you stop believing people could want the real you. You assume they’ll leave once they see your flaws. So you filter, shrink, or mold yourself into something more “palatable.”
But the more we contort ourselves, the harder it is to believe others truly see or love us—because deep down, we know we’re performing.
This is where Laughing in the Face of Chaos inspired me deeply. One line stays with me: “When we let go of the need to be perfect, we free ourselves to live fully—embracing the mess, complexity, and richness of a life that's delightfully real.”
Trust grows when you stop performing—and start allowing.
Final thoughts
If trusting others feels like a battle, you’re not broken—you’re responding to a history that taught you to be careful.
And that history deserves compassion, not shame.
The good news? None of these patterns are fixed. With awareness and courage, you can unlearn the rules that no longer serve you. You can start writing a new script—one built on discernment instead of fear, openness instead of protection.
And remember, as hard as it feels sometimes, rebuilding trust is less about changing others and more about coming home to yourself.
Because the more you trust you—your instincts, your emotions, your boundaries—the more you’ll recognize who’s actually safe to let in.
If You Were a Healing Herb, Which Would You Be?
Each herb holds a unique kind of magic — soothing, awakening, grounding, or clarifying.
This 9-question quiz reveals the healing plant that mirrors your energy right now and what it says about your natural rhythm.
✨ Instant results. Deeply insightful.
