After fifteen years of rebuilding, I've discovered that second marriages demand a different kind of strength — not the careless confidence of youth, but the exhausting vigilance of someone who knows exactly what it costs to fail.
Add VegOut to your Google News feed. 
At 62, I thought I'd figured out how to be someone's husband. I'd done the therapy, read the books, made all the promises to myself about being different this time. What I didn't know was that my body would betray me every single day, defaulting to old patterns like a GPS stuck on an outdated map, constantly trying to navigate me back to the man who'd already failed once.
The muscle memory of failure
Here's what they don't tell you about second marriages: your first instincts are almost always wrong. Not because you're a bad person, but because you're running on programming that's decades old. When Linda tells me she needs something from me, my first impulse is still to solve it with grand gestures rather than consistent presence. When we argue, my body wants to retreat to the kitchen, to work, to anywhere that isn't the messy middle of an uncomfortable conversation.
The divorce that ended my first marriage didn't just break my heart. It rewired my entire nervous system. Now, every small conflict feels like the edge of a cliff. Every moment of distance sends alarm bells through my chest. I love my wife with the intensity of someone who knows exactly what it feels like to lose everything, which means I'm constantly bracing for impact, even on the calmest days.
When being careful becomes its own prison
Linda caught me the other day, standing in the doorway of our bedroom, just watching her read. "You're doing it again," she said without looking up. She meant that thing where I hover, calculating the exact right thing to say, the perfect gesture to make, instead of just walking in and being myself. After fifteen years together, she can spot my overthinking from across the room.
The thing is, I used to be spontaneous. In my twenties and thirties, I was all instinct and appetite, making decisions from my gut. That's what made me good in the kitchen but terrible at home. Now I second-guess everything. Should I work late tonight or disappoint a client? Should I speak up about something bothering me or keep the peace? Every choice feels like it carries the weight of my previous failure.
My therapist calls it hypervigilance, which is a fancy way of saying I'm exhausted from being constantly afraid of screwing up again. The gentleness Linda needs from me doesn't come naturally anymore. It's a conscious choice I have to make dozens of times a day, fighting against every instinct that made me who I was for the first forty-seven years of my life.
The ghost in every argument
We had a fight last month about something stupidly small. I'd forgotten to move the laundry to the dryer before leaving for a consulting gig. Linda wasn't even that upset, just mentioned it in passing. But suddenly I was back in my old kitchen, with my ex-wife listing all the ways I'd let her down, all the small forgettings that added up to neglect.
I overreacted, of course. Apologized too much, promised too many things, turned a minor inconvenience into a production. Linda had to actually stop me mid-spiral. "I'm not her," she said quietly. "And you're not him anymore. Can we just be us?"
But that's the thing about second marriages. You're never just two people. You're two people plus the ghosts of who you used to be, plus the exes who shaped you, plus the kids watching from the sidelines, plus all the scar tissue that makes you flinch at things that shouldn't hurt anymore.
Learning the difference between careful and present
There's this moment every morning where I wake up before Linda and have to make a choice. The old me would already be thinking about the day ahead, mental lists forming before my feet hit the floor. The man I'm trying to be stays in bed for five more minutes, feeling the warmth of her beside me, being grateful for another morning where I get to choose differently.
The restaurant business taught me that timing is everything. Too early and the sauce breaks. Too late and the protein overcooks. But in marriage, especially the second time around, timing isn't about perfection. It's about presence. It's about being there when being there is all that's needed.
Sophie and James told me something at our anniversary dinner last year. They said they could tell I was different from their mom's other dates because I didn't try to impress them. I just showed up, consistently, without needing credit for it. What they didn't know was how hard I had to work to not turn every family dinner into a performance, to not need to be the most interesting person in the room.
The unexpected weight of getting it right
Success in a second marriage carries its own burden. Every good day feels like borrowed time. Every anniversary feels like a miracle. Every moment of easy laughter or comfortable silence feels like something that could evaporate if I'm not careful enough, gentle enough, present enough.
I watch Linda in our garden sometimes, tending to her herbs and vegetables with a patience I'm still learning. She doesn't apologize to the plants for the times she forgets to water them. She doesn't overcorrect when something starts to wilt. She just shows up the next day and does what needs doing. There's a lesson in that, one I'm still trying to learn at 62.
The gentleness required in a second marriage isn't soft. It's fierce in its deliberateness. It's choosing to be vulnerable when armor would be easier. It's admitting you're scared when confidence would be more attractive. It's saying "I don't know how to do this better, but I'm trying" instead of pretending you've got it all figured out.
Final words
The truth about remarrying after a divorce that gutted you is this: you'll never be as carelessly confident as you were the first time, and that's actually the gift. The difficulty of being gentle the second time around isn't a bug, it's a feature. It means you're awake to what you're doing, aware of what you could lose, conscious of every small choice that builds or erodes a marriage.
Some mornings I still wake up surprised to find myself here, in this life I get to try again at. The gentleness Linda and I have built together isn't perfect. It's full of overcorrections and hesitations, moments where we're both trying so hard to get it right that we forget to just be. But it's real, and it's ours, and it's worth every moment of difficult consciousness it requires.
At 62, I've learned that the opposite of taking someone for granted isn't grand gestures or constant vigilance. It's presence, steady and deliberate, showing up even when showing up is hard, especially when showing up is hard. The second marriage is where you learn that love isn't just a feeling or a promise. It's a practice, and practice is always harder when you know exactly how much it costs to get it wrong.
What’s Your Plant-Powered Archetype?
Ever wonder what your everyday habits say about your deeper purpose—and how they ripple out to impact the planet?
This 90-second quiz reveals the plant-powered role you’re here to play, and the tiny shift that makes it even more powerful.
12 fun questions. Instant results. Surprisingly accurate.
