Go to the main content

What your relationship with clutter reveals about your childhood relationship with security

The boxes in your basement and the papers on your desk aren't just clutter—they're a perfectly preserved map of how you learned to feel safe as a child.

Lifestyle

The boxes in your basement and the papers on your desk aren't just clutter—they're a perfectly preserved map of how you learned to feel safe as a child.

Add VegOut to your Google News feed.

Ever walk into someone's home and instantly feel something about their relationship with stuff? I certainly do.

Last year, while helping my parents downsize from the house I grew up in, I found myself sitting on their garage floor, surrounded by boxes of old report cards, every single one showcasing straight A's from elementary school through high school.

My mom had kept them all. As I held those yellowing papers, something clicked about my own relationship with clutter, and why my home office had become a fortress of filed papers, backed-up hard drives, and color-coded everything.

Growing up as an only child in a middle-class suburb with high-achieving parents, I learned early that keeping things meant keeping proof. Proof that I was good enough. Smart enough. Organized enough. And decades later, here I was, still collecting evidence of my worth in banker's boxes.

If you've ever wondered why you can't let go of that stack of magazines you'll never read, or why your closet holds clothes from three different sizes, or why an empty, minimalist space makes you feel anxious rather than peaceful, you're not alone.

📺 Watch our new video: The Lazy Way to Start Going Vegan

Our relationship with clutter often traces back to how we learned to find security as children.

The safety net of stuff

Think about your childhood bedroom for a moment. Was it sparse or packed? Were you allowed to keep your collections, or did your parents regularly purge your belongings? These early experiences shaped how you view possessions today.

Children who grow up in unpredictable environments often become adults who stockpile. It makes perfect sense when you think about it. If you never knew whether there would be enough food, money, or emotional stability, keeping extra everything feels like insurance against chaos.

One client told me she keeps three tubes of toothpaste at all times because as a kid, running out meant going without until the next paycheck.

But here's what surprised me during my own journey: sometimes the opposite is true. Kids from seemingly stable homes can also develop clutter habits, but for different reasons.

In my case, the stability came with strings attached. Achievement equaled love. Performance equaled security. So I kept every certificate, every positive evaluation, every piece of evidence that I was meeting expectations.

Control disguised as organization

For years, I prided myself on being organized. My financial analyst background meant I had spreadsheets for everything. But organization and hoarding can be close cousins when the motivation is control rather than function.

When I finally recognized that my need for control stemmed from childhood anxiety about my parents' approval, the fog started to clear. Those banker's boxes weren't helping me stay organized. They were helping me feel safe.

Every filed receipt, every saved email, every documented accomplishment was a tiny fortress against the fear of not being enough.

Do you find yourself keeping things "just in case"? That phrase often masks deeper fears. Just in case I need proof. Just in case someone questions me. Just in case I forget who I am without these anchors.

The emotional weight of empty spaces

Not everyone hoards, though. Some people swing the opposite direction, maintaining almost sterile environments. This too can trace back to childhood security patterns.

A friend once told me her apartment looked like a hotel room because growing up, her family moved constantly for her dad's job. She learned not to get attached to things or spaces. Her security came from being able to pack up and leave at a moment's notice. Clutter represented roots she couldn't afford to grow.

Others maintain minimal spaces because chaos in childhood made them crave visual calm. If your childhood home was cluttered, noisy, or chaotic, you might find peace in empty surfaces and clear floors. The absence of stuff becomes its own form of security blanket.

Money, clutter, and the security trap

After years of working in finance, then transitioning to writing, I learned something profound: financial security had become a cage I'd built around myself. I kept every financial document, every investment statement, every pay stub, as if these papers were life rafts.

But physical clutter and financial anxiety often dance together. We keep things because we paid for them. We can't donate that bread maker because it was expensive, even though we haven't used it in three years. We hold onto clothes that don't fit because we remember what we paid for them.

This isn't really about the money, though. It's about what money represented in your childhood. Was it scarce? Abundant but conditional? A source of fights? Never discussed? Your answers to these questions probably show up in your closets and drawers today.

Breaking free from childhood patterns

Recognizing these patterns is powerful, but changing them? That's where the real work begins. Start by asking yourself what your clutter is trying to tell you. Not what it says about you being lazy or disorganized, but what it reveals about your deepest needs for security.

When I finally started letting go of those old report cards and certificates, something unexpected happened. The anxiety I thought would consume me never came.

Instead, I felt lighter. Not because minimalism is inherently better, but because I was finally choosing my relationship with stuff rather than operating from childhood programming.

Try this: pick one item you've been holding onto. Hold it and ask yourself, "What am I really keeping here?" Is it the object, or is it a feeling of safety, proof of worth, or protection against loss? Once you identify the real need, you can start meeting it in healthier ways.

Final thoughts

Your relationship with clutter isn't about being good or bad at organizing. It's a window into how you learned to create security in an uncertain world. Whether you're a keeper or a purger, your patterns make sense when you understand their origins.

As I write this from my home office, I can see the progress. Where there once were towers of filed papers, there's now breathing room. Not empty, not minimal, just enough. Enough to feel secure without being imprisoned. Enough to honor my past without being controlled by it.

The goal isn't to achieve someone else's definition of organized or minimalist. It's to understand what your stuff means to you, why it carries that meaning, and whether that meaning still serves the person you are today.

Sometimes the most profound psychological insights come from the simplest questions: Why do I keep this? What am I really holding onto? And what would happen if I let it go?

Your clutter tells a story. Once you understand that story, you get to decide if you want to keep reading it or write a new chapter.

Avery White

Formerly a financial analyst, Avery translates complex research into clear, informative narratives. Her evidence-based approach provides readers with reliable insights, presented with clarity and warmth. Outside of work, Avery enjoys trail running, gardening, and volunteering at local farmers’ markets.

More Articles by Avery

More From Vegout