Whether it's the teddy bear with one missing eye or that stack of participation trophies gathering dust, the childhood items we can't throw away reveal uncomfortable truths about how we're still trying to prove ourselves, seek comfort, or avoid accepting who we've become.
Ever find yourself unable to throw away that ratty teddy bear with one eye missing? Or maybe you've moved three times but somehow that stack of birthday cards from when you turned seven keeps making it into the moving boxes?
Last spring, I helped my parents downsize from the four-bedroom house where I grew up to a smaller condo. As we sorted through decades of accumulated stuff, I found myself clutching items that made zero practical sense to keep.
A participation trophy from fifth-grade soccer (I was terrible). My first diary with a broken lock. Even old report cards that showed my perfectionist tendencies started early.
That experience got me thinking about why we hold onto certain childhood items long after they've served their purpose. After talking with friends and doing some research, I've noticed a pattern.
The items we can't let go of often reveal something deeper about how we process memories, loss, and our own identity.
If you're still holding onto these eight items from your childhood home, you might be deeply sentimental, struggling to process loss, or maybe a bit of both. And that's okay.
Understanding why we keep what we keep is the first step toward deciding what truly deserves space in our lives.
1) Your childhood stuffed animals or blankets
Do you have a teddy bear tucked away in your closet that you'd be mortified if anyone found? You're not alone. These comfort objects represent safety and unconditional love from a time when the world felt simpler.
I kept my childhood stuffed elephant for 30 years. When I finally donated it during my parents' move, I actually cried. Not because I needed the elephant, but because letting go felt like closing a door on that innocent version of myself.
Psychologists call these "transitional objects," and they help children cope with separation anxiety. As adults, keeping them might mean you're holding onto that need for comfort.
There's nothing wrong with sentimentality, but if you're keeping every single stuffed animal from childhood, ask yourself what comfort you're seeking now that you're not getting elsewhere.
2) Report cards and school awards
Found a box of perfect attendance certificates lately? Or maybe honor roll bumper stickers your parents never actually put on the car?
These academic mementos often represent our need for external validation. When I discovered my old report cards during my parents' downsizing, each one screaming "straight A's," I realized I was still that kid seeking gold stars.
At 47 notebooks into my journaling journey, I can tell you that holding onto these papers won't make you feel more accomplished today.
If you're keeping every quiz, test, and certificate from kindergarten through high school, consider what you're trying to prove and to whom. Your worth isn't measured by achievements from decades ago.
3) Birthday cards from people you no longer know
We all have that shoebox somewhere. Cards from your eighth birthday party, signed by kids whose last names you can't remember. Holiday cards from relatives who passed away years ago.
These paper memories feel sacred because they represent connections, even if those connections no longer exist. But here's what I learned while sorting through my own collection: Keeping the card doesn't keep the relationship alive.
One or two meaningful cards? Sure, keep those. But if you're storing every single "Happy 12th Birthday!" card from classmates you haven't thought about in decades, you might be trying to hold onto a version of yourself that had different relationships and different needs.
4) Trophies from activities you quit
That karate trophy from yellow belt? The participation award from Little League? These dust collectors take up surprising amounts of space, both physical and mental.
I kept my fifth-grade soccer trophy for 35 years. I played one season, badly, and spent most games picking dandelions in the outfield. Yet somehow that cheap plastic trophy survived multiple moves.
Why? Because throwing it away felt like admitting failure, even though quitting soccer to focus on things I actually enjoyed was probably one of my first good decisions.
If your childhood bedroom looked like a trophy store exploded, and you're still displaying or storing all of them, consider what story you're telling yourself about needing to preserve every attempt at everything.
5) Clothes that will never fit again
Your high school letter jacket. That prom dress. The shirt you wore on your first day of middle school.
These fabric time capsules are perhaps the most loaded items we keep. They represent not just memories but actual physical versions of ourselves that no longer exist. Keeping them can sometimes mean we're not fully accepting who we've become.
A friend recently admitted she still had her entire Catholic school uniform from twenty years ago. She's not religious anymore, hasn't worn a plaid skirt since graduation, but somehow those clothes remain in her closet.
When we talked about it, she realized she was holding onto them because that was the last time she felt she knew exactly who she was supposed to be.
6) Collections you started but never completed
Baseball cards, stamps, coins, whatever your childhood obsession was. If you've moved these incomplete collections from apartment to apartment, house to house, it might be time to ask why.
Collections represent potential. That stamp collection could be worth something someday. You might get back into collecting coins.
But let's be honest: If you haven't looked at them in a decade, you're not going to suddenly become a numismatist at forty.
These incomplete projects can weigh us down with guilt. Every time you see that binder of basketball cards, you remember you never got that one rookie card you wanted. Instead of inspiration, they become reminders of what we didn't finish.
7) Diaries and journals you're afraid to read
This one hits close to home for someone who's filled 47 notebooks with thoughts since discovering journaling at 36. But those teenage diaries? Different story entirely.
Old journals can be treasures or landmines.
Some people keep them as historical documents of their growth. Others hold onto them out of fear, worry that throwing them away means erasing that version of themselves, even if reading them brings pain or embarrassment.
If you're keeping journals you never open because they're too cringey or painful to read, what purpose are they serving? They're not helping you remember (you're not reading them), and they're not helping you heal (you're avoiding them).
8) Technology that no longer works
That first iPod. Your Nintendo 64. The desktop computer from 1998 that definitely doesn't turn on anymore.
We keep old technology because it represents milestone moments. Your first cell phone was freedom. That ancient laptop got you through college. But broken technology is just expensive garbage with emotional attachments.
During my parents' move, we found my first computer from high school. It hadn't worked in fifteen years, but there it sat in the basement, like a shrine to my teenage years. We couldn't even access any files on it if we wanted to.
It was literally just taking up space because throwing it away felt like throwing away the memories of late-night AIM conversations and badly formatted book reports.
Final thoughts
Look, I'm not saying you need to Marie Kondo your entire childhood. Some items genuinely spark joy and deserve their place in your life. That one special teddy bear? Keep it. Your grandmother's handwritten birthday card? Absolutely.
But if you're holding onto everything, if your basement looks like a childhood museum nobody visits, it might be time to examine what you're really storing. Are these items serving you, or are you serving them?
Processing loss doesn't mean forgetting. You can let go of the soccer trophy and still remember being eight years old on a sunny Saturday. You can donate the stuffed animals and still honor the comfort they gave you.
The truth is, our memories live in us, not our stuff. And sometimes, holding too tightly to physical reminders of the past prevents us from fully embracing who we are now.
Trust me, after finally letting go of those report cards, I feel lighter. Not because I've forgotten my achievements, but because I'm no longer defining myself by the approval of teachers who probably don't remember my name.
What childhood items are you still holding onto? And more importantly, why?
Just launched: Laughing in the Face of Chaos by Rudá Iandê
Exhausted from trying to hold it all together?
You show up. You smile. You say the right things. But under the surface, something’s tightening. Maybe you don’t want to “stay positive” anymore. Maybe you’re done pretending everything’s fine.
This book is your permission slip to stop performing. To understand chaos at its root and all of your emotional layers.
In Laughing in the Face of Chaos, Brazilian shaman Rudá Iandê brings over 30 years of deep, one-on-one work helping people untangle from the roles they’ve been stuck in—so they can return to something real. He exposes the quiet pressure to be good, be successful, be spiritual—and shows how freedom often lives on the other side of that pressure.
This isn’t a book about becoming your best self. It’s about becoming your real self.
