After abandoning my carefully crafted personas and refusing to fake enthusiasm for wine tastings, weekend bar crawls, and office gossip, I watched 20 out of 25 friendships vanish—and discovered that losing them was the price of finding myself.
Add VegOut to your Google News feed. 
Remember that feeling when you laugh at a joke you don't find funny, nod along to music that makes your ears hurt, or spend Saturday nights at bars when you'd rather be home reading?
I spent years doing exactly that. Years pretending to care about things that meant nothing to me, all because I thought that's what it took to maintain friendships and belong somewhere.
When I finally stopped? I lost about 80% of my social circle. And honestly? It was one of the best things that ever happened to me.
The moment everything changed
It started with a wine tasting event. I was there with my finance colleagues, swirling expensive Bordeaux in my glass, pretending to taste hints of black cherry and tobacco or whatever we were supposed to be detecting. The truth? I don't even like wine. Never have.
But there I was, playing the part of sophisticated financial analyst who appreciated the finer things.
That night, something snapped. Maybe it was watching myself in the mirror behind the bar, seeing this person I didn't recognize anymore. Or maybe it was just exhaustion from years of performing. But I decided right then: no more pretending.
The first step was small. I ordered a sparkling water instead of the next round. You'd think I'd announced I was joining a cult based on the reactions I got.
"Are you pregnant?" or "Are you on antibiotics?"
Nobody could fathom that I simply didn't want wine. That was just the beginning.
Peeling back the layers of performance
Once I started paying attention, I realized how much of my life was a carefully constructed performance. I was attending networking events I dreaded, watching sports I couldn't care less about, and engaging in office gossip that left me feeling empty.
Growing up as a "gifted child," I'd learned early that being agreeable and fitting in meant approval and success. Say yes to everything. Be interested in what others are interested in. Never rock the boat. These patterns followed me straight into adulthood and my corporate career.
But here's what nobody tells you about constantly adapting yourself to fit others' expectations: you lose track of who you actually are. I'd become so good at mirroring other people's interests that I genuinely didn't know what I liked anymore.
So I started an experiment. For one month, I would only say yes to things I actually wanted to do. No more pretending to enjoy happy hours when I'd rather go for a run. No more feigning interest in conversations about reality TV shows I'd never watched.
No more laughing at jokes that weren't funny to me.
The fallout was immediate.
Watching the friendships fall away
Within weeks, invitations started drying up. Text threads went quiet. Weekend plans that used to be automatic suddenly didn't include me anymore.
One colleague actually told me I'd become "difficult" because I stopped participating in the Monday morning gossip sessions about weekend drama. Another said I was "no fun anymore" when I declined to join the third bar crawl that month.
The friendship that hurt most to lose was with someone I'd known for five years. We'd bonded over our shared ambition in the finance world, or so I thought. But once I stopped engaging in the constant competition between us, once I stopped playing the game of who had the better promotion or bigger bonus, there was nothing left. She needed someone to measure herself against, and when I stopped being that person, our friendship evaporated.
Out of about 25 people I regularly spent time with, only 5 remained after my authenticity experiment.
What real connection looks like
Those five people? They're still in my life today, years after I left finance to pursue writing. They were the ones who said things like, "Thank god you finally admitted you hate wine," or "I always wondered why you forced yourself through those networking events."
They were the friends who actually knew me, not the performance I was putting on. They stuck around when I started spending weekends trail running instead of brunching. They celebrated when I finally admitted I'd rather discuss books than stock portfolios. They even supported my transition to a plant-based lifestyle, something I'd been interested in for years but never pursued because it didn't fit the image I was maintaining.
These genuine friendships taught me something crucial: real connection happens when you show up as yourself, not as who you think others want you to be. These friends ask me questions about topics I'm actually passionate about. Our conversations have depth because they're rooted in authentic interest, not obligation.
The unexpected benefits of being yourself
Losing most of my social circle was terrifying at first. There were quiet weekends and empty calendars. But slowly, something beautiful emerged from that space.
I discovered I actually love early morning runs when the trails are empty and the world is quiet. I found joy in volunteering at farmers' markets, something I'd never had time for when my weekends were packed with obligatory social events. I started a garden, something my finance friends would have found laughably domestic.
More importantly, I stopped feeling drained all the time. Turns out, pretending to be someone you're not is exhausting. When you're constantly monitoring yourself, adjusting your responses, and performing enthusiasm, you're using enormous amounts of emotional energy.
Now, when I engage with people, it's because I want to be there. When I laugh, it's genuine. When I show interest in something, it's real. This authenticity has attracted new people into my life, people who share my actual interests and values.
What I wish I'd known earlier
Looking back, I wish someone had told me that not all friendships are meant to last forever. Some people are in your life for a specific season or reason, and that's okay.
Those finance colleagues? They were perfect for that phase of my life when I was building my career and learning the ropes.
But holding onto relationships that no longer serve you just because of history or habit? That's not loyalty, it's fear.
I also wish I'd understood sooner that being liked by everyone is impossible and exhausting. When you try to be palatable to all, you become meaningful to none. The people who matter will appreciate your quirks, your real opinions, and your authentic self.
Final thoughts
If you're reading this and recognizing yourself in my story, know that you're not alone. So many of us are walking around pretending, performing, and exhausting ourselves trying to fit into boxes that were never meant for us.
Yes, being authentic might cost you friendships. In my case, it cost me most of them. But what you gain in return? A life that actually feels like yours. Friends who know and love the real you. Energy that's not constantly depleted by performance.
The number of friends you have matters far less than the quality of those connections. My circle is smaller now, but it's real.
And I'll take five authentic friendships over twenty-five performance-based ones any day.
If you're tired of pretending, maybe it's time to stop. The fallout might be bigger than you expect, but the freedom on the other side? That's worth everything you'll lose along the way.
If You Were a Healing Herb, Which Would You Be?
Each herb holds a unique kind of magic — soothing, awakening, grounding, or clarifying.
This 9-question quiz reveals the healing plant that mirrors your energy right now and what it says about your natural rhythm.
✨ Instant results. Deeply insightful.
Avery White
Formerly a financial analyst, Avery translates complex research into clear, informative narratives. Her evidence-based approach provides readers with reliable insights, presented with clarity and warmth. Outside of work, Avery enjoys trail running, gardening, and volunteering at local farmers’ markets.
More Articles by Avery
