Go to the main content

9 behaviors that aren’t frugal—they’re cheap (and everyone notices)

While being smart with money is admirable, there's a cringe-worthy difference between frugal and cheap—and your friends, family, and that server you under-tipped are keeping score.

Lifestyle

While being smart with money is admirable, there's a cringe-worthy difference between frugal and cheap—and your friends, family, and that server you under-tipped are keeping score.

Add VegOut to your Google News feed.

There's a fine line between being financially savvy and being, well, cheap.

I learned this distinction the hard way during my years as a financial analyst. While my colleagues and I all understood the value of smart money management, some took it to an extreme that made everyone uncomfortable.

You know the type: The person who "forgets" their wallet every time the lunch bill arrives, or calculates everyone's share down to the penny, including tax, while conveniently forgetting they ordered extra appetizers.

Being frugal means making thoughtful choices about your money.

Being cheap? That's when your penny-pinching starts affecting others and damages your relationships.

After nearly two decades analyzing financial behavior, I've noticed these patterns repeat themselves.

Trust me, people always notice.

If you're genuinely interested in building wealth while maintaining your dignity and relationships, here are nine behaviors to avoid.

1) Splitting the bill to the exact penny

We've all been there: The dinner check arrives, and suddenly someone whips out their calculator app to determine that they owe $23.47 while you owe $24.12.

Look, I get it, money matters, but when you're haggling over cents with friends who you claim to care about, you're sending a clear message: those few coins matter more than the ease and flow of your relationships.

I once watched a former colleague spend ten minutes arguing that he shouldn't have to contribute to the birthday person's portion of the meal because "nobody told him in advance."

The secondhand embarrassment was palpable. The $8 difference wasn't worth the reputation he earned that night.

A better approach? Take turns picking up the tab, or simply split things evenly.

Yes, sometimes you might pay a few dollars more. Consider it an investment in keeping your friendships intact.

2) Never tipping appropriately

During my monthly money dates with myself, I budget for dining out, and that includes proper tipping. If you can afford to eat at a restaurant, you can afford to tip your server.

Yet I've witnessed too many people leave insulting tips while claiming they're "just being careful with money."

No, you're being inconsiderate.

Servers often make below minimum wage and rely on tips to survive. Your frugality shouldn't come at the expense of someone else's livelihood.

Can't afford to tip 18-20% for good service? Then you can't afford to eat out. It's really that simple.

Cook at home instead, where your thriftiness won't impact anyone else's ability to pay rent.

3) Taking home excessive leftovers or supplies

Free samples at the grocery store aren't meant to be your lunch, and the office coffee supplies aren't for stocking your home pantry.

And please, stop stuffing your pockets with sugar packets and napkins from restaurants.

A friend once invited me to her house and served coffee with sugar packets clearly pilfered from various coffee shops.

Each packet had a different logo. The coffee tasted fine, but my respect for her took a hit.

There's nothing wrong with taking home your actual leftovers or grabbing a reasonable amount of condiments for your to-go order.

However, when you're treating every establishment like your personal supply closet, you've crossed from frugal to cheap.

4) Constantly "forgetting" your wallet

Once is an accident, twice is suspicious, but three times or more? Everyone knows exactly what you're doing.

During my finance days, we had a running joke about one executive who somehow never had his wallet when we went for coffee runs. After a while, people just stopped inviting him.

Was saving $4 on a latte worth being excluded from important informal meetings where real business happened? Definitely not.

If you genuinely forget, pay the person back immediately via Venmo or buy the next round.

Otherwise, you're just freeloading, and everyone knows it.

5) Re-gifting thoughtlessly

There's nothing inherently wrong with re-gifting.

If you received something that's not your style but would be perfect for someone else, go for it.

But when you're obviously passing along unwanted items without thought, like giving your vegetarian friend a steakhouse gift card you got from your boss, or worse, leaving the original gift tag on, you're broadcasting that you couldn't be bothered to spend money OR effort on them.

I once received a birthday present that still had dust on it and a copyright date from five years earlier.

The message was clear: I was an afterthought, a checkbox to tick off. That friendship didn't last much longer.

6) Asking for separate checks everywhere

Yes, you have the right to pay only for what you ordered but, when you're the only one in a group of eight demanding a separate check at a busy restaurant on Saturday night, you're that person.

What really gets me is when people do this after suggesting the expensive restaurant in the first place, or after ordering multiple cocktails while everyone else had water.

You wanted the experience, but not the full cost?

If separate checks matter that much to you, mention it when you're making plans or choosing the restaurant.

Don't spring it on the server and your friends at the end of the meal.

7) Buying the cheapest possible gifts

Gift-giving is about showing you care but, when you consistently give the clearance rack candle that smells like industrial cleaner, or the obvious dollar store item for weddings and birthdays, you're telling people exactly how much they mean to you.

During my high-earning finance years, I knew colleagues pulling in six figures who would contribute the bare minimum to group gifts or buy the cheapest item on a wedding registry. These same people would then brag about their expensive vacations.

The math didn't add up, and neither did the respect they thought they commanded.

8) Negotiating everything inappropriately

Negotiating is a valuable skill.

I've used it to save thousands on cars and homes but, when you're haggling with the teenager at the farmers market over the price of locally grown tomatoes, or trying to get a discount on your friend's handmade jewelry, you're not being savvy.

You're being cheap.

Know when negotiation is appropriate and when it's insulting.

Corporate services, large purchases, and situations where negotiation is expected? Go for it.

Small businesses, artists, and service workers trying to make a living? Pay the asking price or shop elsewhere.

9) Always choosing money over experiences

Perhaps the most telling behavior I've observed, both in myself and others, is consistently choosing to save a few dollars over creating memories or showing up for people.

Skipping your best friend's destination wedding to save money while posting about your new designer bag? Missing family gatherings because the gas money "adds up" while planning expensive hobbies?

These choices show your priorities clearly, and people remember them.

After witnessing the 2008 financial crisis and seeing how quickly fortunes can change, I learned that relationships and experiences are the only real wealth we have.

Yes, save money and be smart, but not at the cost of the connections that make life worth living.

Final thoughts

Being financially responsible is admirable. Building wealth, saving for the future, and spending consciously are all positive behaviors.

However, when your frugality consistently inconveniences others, damages relationships, or takes advantage of people's generosity, you've crossed into cheap territory.

The irony? Being cheap often costs you more in the long run.

Those saved dollars won't compensate for lost friendships, missed opportunities, or a reputation as someone who values money over people.

True wealth is about the richness of your relationships and experiences, and those are investments that always pay dividends.

Just launched: Laughing in the Face of Chaos by Rudá Iandê

Exhausted from trying to hold it all together?
You show up. You smile. You say the right things. But under the surface, something’s tightening. Maybe you don’t want to “stay positive” anymore. Maybe you’re done pretending everything’s fine.

This book is your permission slip to stop performing. To understand chaos at its root and all of your emotional layers.

In Laughing in the Face of Chaos, Brazilian shaman Rudá Iandê brings over 30 years of deep, one-on-one work helping people untangle from the roles they’ve been stuck in—so they can return to something real. He exposes the quiet pressure to be good, be successful, be spiritual—and shows how freedom often lives on the other side of that pressure.

This isn’t a book about becoming your best self. It’s about becoming your real self.

👉 Explore the book here

 

Avery White

Formerly a financial analyst, Avery translates complex research into clear, informative narratives. Her evidence-based approach provides readers with reliable insights, presented with clarity and warmth. Outside of work, Avery enjoys trail running, gardening, and volunteering at local farmers’ markets.

More Articles by Avery

More From Vegout