After four decades of meticulous planning and saving, she discovered that the perfect retirement she'd built was actually the perfect trap—empty days, lost identity, and a loneliness that her beach house and travel fund couldn't cure.
When I met Margaret at a local coffee shop last month, she told me something that stopped me in my tracks. At 70, after decades of careful planning and disciplined saving, she was miserable in retirement. The life she'd worked so hard to create felt empty, purposeless, and nothing like the golden years she'd imagined.
Her story hit close to home. As someone who spent nearly 20 years as a financial analyst, I've seen countless retirement plans. I've crunched the numbers, analyzed the portfolios, and helped people map out their futures. But Margaret's confession reminded me of something crucial that spreadsheets can't capture: the human side of retirement that no amount of financial planning can prepare you for.
What struck me most was how common Margaret's experience actually is. Research shows that depression rates spike in the first few years of retirement, and many retirees struggle with loss of identity, purpose, and social connections. Yet we rarely talk about this dark side of the dream we're all supposedly working toward.
1. The retirement myth we've all bought into
Growing up, what did you picture when you thought about retirement? Golf courses? Cruises? Endless days of leisure?
For most of us, retirement represents freedom from work, stress, and obligations. It's the carrot at the end of a very long stick. But here's what Margaret discovered, and what many retirees learn too late: that vision of retirement is fundamentally flawed.
The problem starts with how we frame retirement. We see it as an escape from work rather than a transition to something meaningful. During my finance days, I watched clients pour everything into their retirement accounts while neglecting to think about what they'd actually do with all that free time.
Margaret had saved diligently since she was 30. She had the beach house, the travel fund, the hobby budget. On paper, everything was perfect. But six months into retirement, she found herself watching the clock, feeling useless, and wondering if this was all there was.
The retirement industry sells us on numbers: save this much, invest in these funds, withdraw at this rate. What it doesn't tell us is that humans need purpose, connection, and growth at every stage of life. Without these elements, even the most comfortable retirement can feel like a prison.
2. Why endless leisure becomes a burden
Remember when you were a kid and summer vacation stretched out forever? The first week was amazing, but by week three, you might have been secretly ready to go back to school.
Margaret's retirement felt like an endless summer vacation that had lost its charm. She told me she'd wake up with nothing urgent to do, no meetings to attend, no deadlines to meet. At first, it felt liberating. Within months, it felt suffocating.
Psychologists call this the "paradox of choice." When you have unlimited options and no structure, decision fatigue sets in. Should you read? Garden? Watch TV? Visit friends? When everything is possible, nothing feels important.
I saw this same pattern during my transition out of finance. After years of 70-hour weeks, I thought I'd love having endless free time. Instead, I found myself creating arbitrary schedules and to-do lists just to feel productive. The belief that rest was laziness, drilled into me during those intense analyst years, didn't disappear just because I had more time.
Margaret described spending hours planning elaborate meals she didn't really want to eat, organizing closets that didn't need organizing, and taking up hobbies she didn't actually enjoy. She was filling time rather than living it.
3. The identity crisis nobody warns you about
Who are you without your job title?
It's a question that blindsided Margaret completely. For 40 years, she'd been a teacher. She had a role, a purpose, a clear identity. Students needed her. Parents respected her. Colleagues valued her input.
Then retirement came, and suddenly she was just Margaret. Not Mrs. Thompson the teacher. Just Margaret, with no clear role or contribution to make.
This identity shift is brutal, and it's something I experienced firsthand when leaving finance. For years, I'd introduced myself as a financial analyst. It gave me instant credibility and a sense of worth. Without that title, I felt invisible and insignificant.
Margaret told me about attending a neighborhood party where someone asked what she did. "I'm retired," she said, and watched as the person's interest visibly waned. They moved on to someone else, someone still in the game, someone with stories about work and achievements and challenges.
The loss of professional identity can trigger a deeper existential crisis. If you're not contributing to society, if you're not producing or achieving, what's your value? It's a harsh question, but one that many retirees silently grapple with.
4. The surprising loneliness of freedom
Think about how many of your social connections come from work. The colleague you grab lunch with. The team you collaborate with on projects. The casual conversations by the coffee machine.
Margaret hadn't realized how much her social life revolved around school until it was gone. Her teacher friends were still working. Her adult children had their own busy lives. Her husband had passed away five years earlier. Suddenly, she could go days without meaningful human interaction.
Loneliness in retirement is epidemic. A study by the University of Michigan found that 28% of retirees feel isolated from others. That isolation isn't just emotionally painful; it's physically harmful, increasing the risk of heart disease, stroke, and premature death.
Margaret tried joining clubs and volunteer organizations, but it wasn't the same as the natural camaraderie that develops when you're working toward shared goals with colleagues. The connections felt forced, superficial.
She described sitting in her beautiful beach house, looking out at the ocean, and feeling utterly alone. All that planning, all that saving, and she'd created a gilded cage.
5. Redesigning retirement for real fulfillment
So what changed for Margaret? How did she transform her miserable retirement into something meaningful?
The shift began when she stopped seeing retirement as an ending and started seeing it as a beginning. Instead of retiring from something, she decided to retire to something.
She went back to work, but not in the traditional sense. She started tutoring kids who were struggling in school, working just 15 hours a week. It gave her structure without overwhelming her schedule. More importantly, it gave her purpose.
She also challenged the idea that retirement meant complete independence. She moved closer to her daughter's family, becoming an active grandmother. She joined a hiking group that met three times a week. She started a book club that focused on memoirs, combining her love of reading with meaningful discussions about life experiences.
What Margaret discovered aligns with what researchers call "encore careers" or "retirement 2.0." It's about finding the sweet spot between total leisure and full-time work, between independence and community, between rest and purpose.
Finding your own path forward
Margaret's story isn't unique. Millions of retirees are quietly struggling with the same issues, wondering why the life they planned so carefully feels so empty.
If you're approaching retirement or already there, consider this: What if retirement isn't about stopping work entirely? What if it's about finally having the freedom to do work that matters to you, on your terms?
The financial planning is important, yes. But equally important is planning for purpose, connection, and growth. Ask yourself: What would make you jump out of bed in the morning at 70? What problems do you want to solve? What legacy do you want to create?
Margaret is 73 now. She still lives by the beach, still travels, still enjoys her hobbies. But she also tutors three days a week, babysits her grandkids every Friday, and leads her hiking group on challenging trails. She's busier than many working people, but it's a chosen busyness, a purposeful engagement with life.
The retirement she'd planned for 40 years nearly destroyed her. The retirement she created for herself saved her. Maybe it's time we all rethink what those golden years should really look like.
Just launched: Laughing in the Face of Chaos by Rudá Iandê
Exhausted from trying to hold it all together?
You show up. You smile. You say the right things. But under the surface, something’s tightening. Maybe you don’t want to “stay positive” anymore. Maybe you’re done pretending everything’s fine.
This book is your permission slip to stop performing. To understand chaos at its root and all of your emotional layers.
In Laughing in the Face of Chaos, Brazilian shaman Rudá Iandê brings over 30 years of deep, one-on-one work helping people untangle from the roles they’ve been stuck in—so they can return to something real. He exposes the quiet pressure to be good, be successful, be spiritual—and shows how freedom often lives on the other side of that pressure.
This isn’t a book about becoming your best self. It’s about becoming your real self.
