While younger generations smile politely at crystal decanters and china sets, they're secretly wondering how to fit these dust-collectors into their studio apartments alongside their collection of unused monogrammed towels and encyclopedia sets.
Ever wonder why that expensive paperweight from your in-laws is collecting dust on your shelf?
Last month, I watched my friend unwrap a crystal decanter set at her birthday party. The gift-giver, her well-meaning mother, beamed with pride while explaining how it was perfect for entertaining. My friend smiled politely, but I caught her eye roll. She lives in a studio apartment and drinks wine straight from the bottle like the rest of us millennials.
This got me thinking about the generational gift-giving gap I've witnessed over and over. When I left my finance job to pursue writing, one of my former colleagues gifted me an elaborate fountain pen set. While I appreciated the gesture, I do all my writing on a laptop. That beautiful pen case? Still unopened three years later.
The truth is, what older generations consider thoughtful often misses the mark for younger folks. And before anyone gets offended, this isn't about being ungrateful. It's about understanding how different generations value different things. After countless conversations with friends and readers about their "thanks but no thanks" gift experiences, I've compiled the most common culprits.
1. China sets and formal dinnerware
Remember when having a complete china set was a status symbol? Well, most millennials and Gen Zers are eating takeout off paper plates or using their one good bowl for everything from cereal to pasta.
The formal dining tradition just doesn't fit modern lifestyles. Many younger people move frequently, live in smaller spaces, or simply prefer minimalism over cabinets full of dishes they'll use once a year. If you want to give something kitchen-related, think practical: a really good chef's knife or that trendy air fryer everyone's talking about.
2. Encyclopedia sets and reference books
A partner at my old finance firm once proudly gifted his nephew a leather-bound encyclopedia set for graduation. The kid's face was priceless. In an age where we can Google anything in seconds, these beautiful but bulky books feel more like decoration than education.
Physical reference materials might hold sentimental value for those who grew up with them, but for digital natives, they're essentially expensive doorstops. The information becomes outdated quickly, and honestly, when was the last time anyone under 40 cracked open a physical dictionary?
3. Decorative figurines and collectibles
Precious Moments figurines, commemorative plates, crystal animals... these items that once graced every boomer household now make younger recipients internally groan. I have a collection of these from various relatives, all carefully boxed in my closet because I feel too guilty to donate them.
Young adults today lean toward experiences over objects. They're trying to declutter, not add more knick-knacks to dust. Plus, with many people renting rather than owning homes, displaying fragile collectibles isn't exactly practical when you're moving every couple of years.
4. Monogrammed anything
Monogrammed towels, robes, luggage tags, you name it. While personalization sounds thoughtful in theory, it often backfires. First off, trends change. That monogrammed leather briefcase might have been perfect in 1995, but it looks pretty out of place in today's casual work environment.
There's also the awkward reality of relationships ending. A friend of mine has a whole set of monogrammed items with her married initials from a marriage that lasted two years. Now what? You can't regift them, can't donate them easily, and they serve as expensive reminders of changed circumstances.
5. Paper savings bonds
Growing up, savings bonds were the go-to gift from grandparents. But have you tried cashing one recently? The process is surprisingly complicated, especially if you've moved since receiving it or changed your name.
Younger generations prefer digital financial gifts: Venmo, Zelle, or contributions to investment apps they actually use. Even better? Many would rather have help with immediate financial needs like student loan payments than money tied up for decades.
6. Cable TV subscriptions or landline phones
Yes, this actually happens. Well-meaning relatives still gift cable packages or offer to pay for landline installation. Meanwhile, most people under 40 haven't had cable in years and consider landlines completely obsolete.
We're living in the streaming age. Netflix, Spotify, or even a year of their favorite app subscription would be infinitely more useful. Or better yet, ask which services they actually use instead of assuming everyone still watches regular TV.
7. Self-help books from another era
"How to Succeed in Business" books from the 80s, relationship guides that assume traditional gender roles, or career advice that suggests showing up with your resume in person... these outdated self-help books are given with good intentions but land with a thud.
The working world has changed dramatically. Remote work, gig economy, social media marketing - none of these existed when many of these books were written. If you want to give helpful reading material, make sure it's relevant to today's world, not yesterday's.
8. Fancy stationery sets
Beautiful letterhead, embossed envelopes, wax seals... they're gorgeous, but when was the last time anyone under 50 wrote an actual letter? Most communication happens via text, email, or DM. Even thank you notes have gone digital.
I received an expensive stationery set when I started my writing career. The gift-giver assumed writers love beautiful paper. But like most writers today, I type everything. That stationery is still pristine in its box, making me feel guilty every time I see it.
9. Department store gift cards
This one might surprise you, but those Macy's and JCPenney gift cards often go unused by younger recipients. These stores, staples for boomer shopping, don't resonate with generations who buy everything online or from completely different retailers.
Young adults shop at Target, Amazon, or specialty online stores. They thrift, use subscription services, or buy directly from brands on social media. A gift card to a traditional department store often feels like homework - forcing them to shop somewhere they'd never normally go.
Final thoughts
Reading this list might make it seem like younger generations are impossible to please. That's not true at all. They just value different things: experiences over objects, practicality over tradition, and digital solutions over physical ones.
The best gift you can give? Ask what someone actually wants or needs. It might feel less surprising, but it's infinitely more thoughtful than guessing based on what you would have wanted at their age. Times change, and that's okay.
And if you're a younger person who's received these gifts, remember the thought behind them. That china set might not fit your lifestyle, but it represents someone trying to give you something they consider valuable. Grace and gratitude go a long way, even when the gift itself doesn't.
What’s Your Plant-Powered Archetype?
Ever wonder what your everyday habits say about your deeper purpose—and how they ripple out to impact the planet?
This 90-second quiz reveals the plant-powered role you’re here to play, and the tiny shift that makes it even more powerful.
12 fun questions. Instant results. Surprisingly accurate.
