When I learned that expensive bottles don't always mean what I thought they did.
I spent my twenties thinking I'd figured out sophisticated perfume. Heavy glass bottle with a designer name? Must be fancy. I wore these scents confidently, not realizing the signals were more complicated than I'd assumed.
The realization came during a work event. A woman I admired complimented my dress, then paused when I walked past. "Nice perfume," she said in a tone I couldn't quite read. That's when I started noticing patterns in what different people wore.
1. Heavily advertised fragrances
I used to save up for perfumes I saw in magazine spreads and commercials. The ones with dramatic visuals and celebrity endorsements felt aspirational.
What I eventually noticed was a pattern. The fragrances that required the most advertising seemed to be the ones I stopped seeing in certain contexts. High-end brands often rely on word-of-mouth rather than mass market visibility.
Perfumes advertised everywhere are designed for broad appeal. They smell fine, and plenty of people love them. But if you're aiming for understated elegance, mass market visibility works against that goal.
2. Celebrity-branded fragrances
I bought several celebrity perfumes in my twenties. They came in appealing bottles and felt like a reasonable splurge. I assumed I was accessing someone's personal taste.
Celebrity fragrances are usually licensing arrangements. The famous person approves packaging and shows up for launches, but the actual scent is created by standard manufacturers using similar processes to more affordable brands.
If you love how they smell, that's completely valid. But as status markers, they tend to signal different things than intended. The association is more about the celebrity than about fragrance knowledge.
3. Very strong, projecting scents
For years, I wore perfume that announced my presence before I entered a room. I thought impact was the goal. Make an entrance. Be memorable.
What I didn't consider was that strong scents can be overwhelming in shared spaces. Many people have genuine physical reactions to heavy fragrances, which makes subtlety a more considerate choice.
The pattern I noticed was that more expensive perfumes tend to stay close to the skin. They're noticeable up close but don't broadcast across rooms. It's a different approach to presence, one that feels more intentional.
4. Gift-with-purchase staples
I used to think perfumes in holiday gift sets represented a brand's best offerings. Beautiful packaging, bonus with purchase, must be special.
What these actually represent are volume drivers. They're products the brand wants to move in quantity. Nothing wrong with that, but it's a different category than what's purchased at the fragrance counter by people seeking something specific.
The economics make sense. Gift sets introduce products to new customers at accessible price points. But accessibility and exclusivity work in opposite directions. The wider the distribution, the less rare something feels.
5. Bottles designed as decorative objects
I owned perfumes in bottles shaped like a woman's torso and a high-heeled shoe. The creative packaging felt collectible, worth displaying.
Here's what I eventually understood. When packaging becomes the primary selling point, it usually means the fragrance itself can't compete on scent or reputation alone. The bottle is doing the work that the contents can't.
Higher-end perfumes typically come in surprisingly simple bottles. Clean lines, minimal decoration, sometimes almost austere. The fragrance carries the value. When bottle design dominates the marketing, it suggests a different target audience and price philosophy.
Final thoughts
If you love any of these fragrances, wear them with confidence. Personal preference matters more than any social coding. But if you're curious about why certain scents show up in some contexts and not others, these patterns exist.
Class signaling through consumer goods is real, even when we'd rather it wasn't. Some people learn these unspoken rules early. Others figure them out later through observation and the occasional uncomfortable realization. Neither approach makes anyone better or worse.
What I wear now is quieter and less obviously branded. It costs about the same but reads differently. The main change is that nobody comments on it, which I've learned often means you've found the right register. Sometimes the goal isn't to be noticed. It's to feel like you belong without announcing you're trying.
What’s Your Plant-Powered Archetype?
Ever wonder what your everyday habits say about your deeper purpose—and how they ripple out to impact the planet?
This 90-second quiz reveals the plant-powered role you’re here to play, and the tiny shift that makes it even more powerful.
12 fun questions. Instant results. Surprisingly accurate.