The gap between what sounds like vacation heaven and vacation hell might say more about how we think about leisure than the activities themselves.
My partner's parents came back from an Alaska cruise last year absolutely glowing. They couldn't stop talking about the formal dinners, the port lectures, the couple from Toronto they befriended at their assigned table.
Meanwhile, I was internally dying at the thought of eating dinner at the same table with strangers every single night at exactly 6:30 pm.
That conversation got me thinking about how differently generations approach cruise vacations. While the industry chases younger travelers with rock climbing walls and DJ pool parties, there's a whole category of traditional cruise experiences that boomers genuinely love. The same experiences that make most people my age immediately want to change the subject.
1) Formal night with assigned seating
Getting dressed up in semiformal attire, showing up at exactly 6:30 pm, and sitting at the same table with the same strangers every single night sounds like social hell to most younger travelers.
But boomers often request this experience specifically. They enjoy the ritual of it. The predictability. Getting to know their tablemates over the course of a week.
When I asked my partner's mom why they chose traditional dining over flexible seating, she said something that stuck with me: "We met the most interesting couple from Toronto. By the third night, we were sharing stories like old friends."
The younger crowd wants options, flexibility, the ability to eat whenever hunger strikes. Boomers seem to appreciate the structure. It's the difference between viewing constraints as limiting versus viewing them as creating connection.
2) Attended port lectures
Before arriving at each destination, cruise ships offer educational lectures about the history, culture, and highlights of the upcoming port.
These lectures apparently fill up with older travelers taking notes. Actual notes. With pens and small notebooks they brought specifically for this purpose.
Most younger cruisers skip these entirely in favor of quick searches or blog posts about the "top 10 things to do" in whichever port they're visiting.
The difference isn't about who's more informed. It's about the experience of learning. Boomers seem to value the lecture format itself, the expertise of a speaker, the communal aspect of sitting in a room and absorbing information together. Younger travelers want information when they want it, in digestible chunks, preferably with user reviews.
3) Traditional buffet dining
While newer cruise lines are ditching buffets entirely in favor of multiple specialty restaurants, many boomers still consider the buffet the heart of the cruise experience.
They like surveying all the options, making multiple trips, trying a little bit of everything. The abundance itself is part of the appeal.
I've mentioned this before but this reminds me of something my grandmother used to say. She grew up during leaner times, and abundance always meant something to her generation. A buffet isn't just convenient food. It represents choice, plenty, the ability to have seconds or thirds without judgment.
Younger cruisers tend to see buffets as chaotic, potentially unsanitary, and honestly kind of depressing. We'd rather wait for a table at a specific restaurant with a curated menu.
4) Cruise ship bingo
Bingo on cruise ships isn't free. You're paying actual money to play, and the bingo halls still fill up with older passengers who play multiple cards simultaneously with the focus of chess players.
To younger travelers, this sounds absolutely wild. Pay money to play bingo? On vacation? When you could be doing literally anything else?
But talk to any cruise veteran and they'll tell you the bingo crowd is serious. Some passengers apparently plan their entire cruise schedule around game times.
It's about the communal competition, the simple pleasure of a game that doesn't require learning complex rules or physical exertion. It's social without requiring deep conversation. You can play next to someone for an hour and feel connected without exchanging life stories.
5) Piano bar entertainment
Most cruise ships have a piano bar where a musician takes requests, leads sing-alongs, and plays standards from the Great American Songbook. These venues pack out with older cruisers who know all the words to songs from before I was born.
My generation walks past these spaces on our way to the nightclub. The appeal is completely lost on us. Who wants to sit in a dim bar singing "Piano Man" with strangers when there's a DJ playing house music three decks up?
But I get it now in a way I didn't five years ago. There's something about shared cultural touchstones, about everyone in a room knowing the same songs, that creates instant community. Younger travelers don't have that same experience because our music consumption is so fragmented and individualized.
The piano bar isn't about the music quality. It's about collective memory.
6) Organized deck activities and games
Trivia contests. Water aerobics. Napkin folding demonstrations. Dance lessons. These scheduled activities happen throughout the day, and the cruise director announces them over the loudspeaker.
Boomers show up. They participate. They seem to genuinely enjoy having their day structured with options.
Most younger cruisers find this kind of programming either charmingly retro or mildly dystopian, depending on their mood. We're more likely to create our own entertainment, sleep in, or work remotely from a deck chair.
The generational divide here isn't about fun versus boring. It's about approaches to leisure time itself. One generation seems more comfortable with organized recreation. The other views scheduling as something that happens at work, not on vacation.
7) Multi-week voyages
River cruises and longer ocean voyages of two to three weeks attract overwhelmingly older travelers. These extended trips allow for slower pacing, more time in each port, leisurely sea days without feeling rushed.
For younger travelers still in the workforce, this length of vacation is usually impossible. But even when we have the time, most of us don't want to commit to that long on a single trip. A week feels long. Two weeks feels ambitious. Three weeks on the same ship sounds suffocating.
But I've noticed something in conversations with older cruisers. They describe these longer voyages as a chance to genuinely unwind, to stop thinking about what comes next, to settle into a rhythm. They're not trying to maximize destinations or Instagram moments. They're savoring slowness.
In a world that increasingly values efficiency and optimization, there's something almost radical about three weeks on a ship going nowhere in particular.
8) Traditional enrichment programs
Many cruise lines offer art auctions, wine tastings, investment seminars, and cooking demonstrations. These programs skew heavily toward older passengers.
Younger cruisers largely avoid these, viewing them as thinly veiled sales pitches or boring educational content we could find online. Which, to be fair, is often accurate.
But I think we're missing something here. These programs work because they provide structure and purpose to sea days. They give you something to look forward to, a reason to show up somewhere at a specific time, a shared experience with other passengers.
For retirees with unlimited time and fewer default social structures, these scheduled activities serve a function beyond their stated purpose. They create routine in an unstructured environment. They facilitate connection with fellow travelers.
Conclusion
What strikes me most about these preferences isn't that boomers are wrong or outdated. It's that their cruise experiences reflect genuinely different values around community, structure, and leisure time.
They seem more comfortable with constraints, more interested in depth than breadth, more willing to commit to experiences that unfold slowly. Meanwhile, younger travelers prioritize flexibility, novelty, and the feeling of unlimited options.
Neither approach is better. They're just different maps for the same journey.
The cruise industry knows this, which is why they're trying to serve both markets simultaneously with everything from formal dining rooms to adults-only party ships. The real question isn't which generation has it figured out.
It's whether we can learn anything from each other's approach to vacation before we're the ones requesting assigned seating and early dinner times ourselves.
What’s Your Plant-Powered Archetype?
Ever wonder what your everyday habits say about your deeper purpose—and how they ripple out to impact the planet?
This 90-second quiz reveals the plant-powered role you’re here to play, and the tiny shift that makes it even more powerful.
12 fun questions. Instant results. Surprisingly accurate.
