When I overheard a 60-year-old woman at a Venice café say quitting coffee changed her life, I had questions.
It started like a cliché: me, ordering a double espresso at a sun-drenched café in Venice Beach, eavesdropping on strangers while pretending to read.
She was seated two tables away, sipping an iced matcha with oat milk and talking to a friend about her post-coffee life.
That phrase caught my attention.
“Post-coffee,” like she had exited a cult, or maybe a war. But what struck me most was her energy — not jittery, not slow. Just… steady. She looked like someone who slept well and meant it.
I leaned in a little closer. She said something that stuck:
“When I quit coffee at 60, I didn’t think much would change. But I feel sharper now than I did at 30.”
Of course, I had to talk to her. Her name was Claudine, a retired architect turned ceramics teacher. We ended up chatting for nearly an hour. And by the end, I wasn’t just reconsidering my second espresso — I was rethinking the entire mythology of caffeine.
The “normal” she walked away from
Claudine told me she’d been a two-to-three cup a day drinker for over four decades.
Coffee had seen her through all-nighters in grad school, early-morning meetings in her firm, the toddler years, the divorce, and her second act as an artist.
“I didn’t think of it as a crutch,” she said. “It was just what you did.”
But after turning 60, she started noticing things: shaky hands that made her nervous at the pottery wheel. Racing thoughts during sleep. A feeling that her days were rushed—even when she had nowhere to be.
The worst part?
Her focus was fragmented. “Like I was revving my engine but never leaving the driveway,” she said.
So she did something radical: she stopped.
The withdrawal—and the surprising reset
The first week was, in her words, “hell in a French press.” Claudine had migraines, fatigue, and a strange, hollow sadness that followed her like a shadow.
But by week two, her body started recalibrating. Her sleep deepened. Her mornings became slower, gentler. “It felt like landing in my body after being stuck in my head for years,” she said.
Her story reminded me of what neuroscientists have documented: caffeine blocks adenosine, the chemical that helps us feel sleepy—but once removed, the brain begins to balance itself naturally.
Why focus improved after coffee
Here’s the kicker: Claudine didn’t just feel calmer—she felt sharper.
This seemed counterintuitive. Isn’t caffeine supposed to help with focus?
And yet, multiple studies have shown that while caffeine can improve alertness in the sleep-deprived, it doesn’t always boost performance in the well-rested.
In fact, after withdrawal, many people report better sustained attention without the peaks and crashes.
Claudine said she noticed herself finishing books again. Feeling more present in conversations. “I stopped interrupting people just to keep up the pace,” she said. “I actually heard them.”
Matcha: her bridge drink
When I asked what replaced coffee, Claudine smiled. “Matcha. But only once or twice a week. It’s ceremonial, not compulsive.”
She prepares it slowly. Whisks it by hand. Drinks it in silence before opening her kiln.
Unlike coffee, matcha delivers L-theanine, an amino acid that promotes calm without drowsiness. Combined with its moderate caffeine content, it creates a unique effect: alert but relaxed.
Claudine called it “mental jazz without the cymbals.”
The bigger picture: caffeine and aging brains
Our conversation veered philosophical.
Claudine believes caffeine masks natural rhythms — particularly in later life. “I thought I was just tired because I was aging,” she said. “Turns out, I was tired because I was caffeinating over fatigue instead of fixing it.”
Turns out she’s not alone.
According to a 2018 study in Nutrition, excessive caffeine in older adults can interfere with deep sleep and worsen anxiety symptoms — two issues already more common after 50.
And in older brains that metabolize caffeine more slowly, the effects can last far longer than we think.
How her life changed—beyond focus
Claudine didn’t sell me on her story with science. She sold me on the details.
- She said her digestion improved. (“I didn’t realize coffee was bloating me.”)
- She said her nails got stronger. (“No more dehydration cracks.”)
- She said she stopped needing melatonin.
- She laughed more. Took more walks. Texted less.
“I’m not saying coffee ruined my life,” she said. “But I do think it kept me from feeling it fully.”
My own experiment
I’m not at Claudine’s level yet. But that night, I skipped my usual espresso martini. I made tea instead. I even googled “where to buy ceremonial matcha” at midnight.
And while I haven’t quit coffee (yet), I’ve started asking better questions:
- Am I drinking this to feel good or to stop feeling bad?
- Am I awake or just artificially animated?
Meeting Claudine reminded me that we can rewire ourselves at any age. That “how it’s always been” isn’t the same as “how it has to be.”
And that sometimes, the most powerful reboot starts with simply… stepping off the buzz.
Final thoughts
We love to romanticize coffee. The mug. The ritual. The aroma. But as Claudine’s story showed me, romance can turn into reliance.
Her post-coffee life isn’t anti-pleasure — it’s just anti-numbness. She’s traded stimulation for clarity, speed for presence. And in doing so, she’s reminded me (and now, maybe you) that there’s a whole world waiting on the other side of the crash.
Whether it’s matcha, mindfulness, or just morning stillness — it’s worth exploring.
Even if you’re only half her age.
If You Were a Healing Herb, Which Would You Be?
Each herb holds a unique kind of magic — soothing, awakening, grounding, or clarifying.
This 9-question quiz reveals the healing plant that mirrors your energy right now and what it says about your natural rhythm.
✨ Instant results. Deeply insightful.
