The one regret people in their 40s keep quiet: all the time they spent trying to be someone else’s idea of happy

There’s a conversation that happens in coffee shops and therapy offices across the country, whispered between people who’ve crossed into their 40s. It’s not about the wrinkles or the metabolism or the way their knees sound now. It’s about time—specifically, all the time spent becoming a person they’re still not sure they wanted to be.

I first noticed it when my friend Sarah turned 42. We were catching up after months apart, and somewhere between the weather small talk and the kids-are-growing updates, she looked directly at me and said, “I just realized I don’t know what I actually want anymore. I’ve spent twenty years wanting what other people wanted for me.” The vulnerability in her voice was striking—not sad, exactly, but tinged with the particular exhaustion that comes from laying down a backpack you’ve been carrying so long you forgot you could put it down.

This isn’t unique to Sarah. Psychologists have been documenting something quietly significant: midlife isn’t just about reassessing your career or your relationships. It’s about confronting the person you’ve become in service to everyone else’s expectations.

The architecture of other people’s dreams

When we’re young, we’re told that happiness is a destination. Follow these steps, make these choices, achieve these milestones—and you’ll arrive at contentment. Your parents want you to be successful. Your teachers want you to be accomplished. Your culture wants you to be productive. Your partner wants you to be supportive. Your industry wants you to be competitive. Your social circle wants you to be fun but not too much, authentic but not weird, ambitious but not threatening.

We spend decades trying to thread this needle.

By 40, something shifts. You realize you’ve been running a race where the finish line kept moving, designed by people who weren’t even in the stands. And here’s the particular cruelty of it: you’re probably pretty good at being what everyone wanted. Maybe you have the job, the relationship structure, the lifestyle that looked good on paper. But something fundamental feels borrowed—like you’re wearing someone else’s life with your name on the lease.

Research on identity and midlife development suggests this isn’t just an emotional observation.

Recent studies show that loneliness in midlife—including the loneliness of feeling unknown even in relationships—has increased significantly in recent decades

. Part of this pattern traces back to the gap between who we’ve become and who we actually are.

The cost of performed happiness

There’s a specific pain in spending 20 years being someone else’s version of happy. It’s not dramatic or obvious. It’s the small, repeated denial of yourself—the jokes you don’t make because they might confuse your image, the dreams you downplay because they don’t fit the narrative, the preferences you’ve talked yourself out of so many times you forget they were ever yours.

When you hit 40 and something cracks open—whether it’s a health scare, a relationship ending, or just the accumulation of small betrayals—you start wondering who you’ve actually been. And more painfully, who you could have been if you’d taken yourself seriously earlier.

I interviewed a woman named James who told me she spent her entire 30s building a career that looked impressive on LinkedIn but left her hollow. She was good at it. She was promoted. People envied her trajectory. But it was a path her father had wanted, not one she’d chosen. By 42, she’d left that job entirely—not for something better or more lucrative, but for something more honest. The cost of that decision, she said, wasn’t financial. It was the cost of admitting she’d wasted time, which somehow feels worse than the money.

There’s also the relational cost. When you’ve spent years performing a version of yourself, the people closest to you have fallen in love with or committed to that performance. Changing means risking that they won’t like who you actually are. Some people decide the risk is worth it. Others stay in the shape they’ve been squeezed into, which is its own kind of loss.

The both/and of it

Here’s what complicates this narrative—and what makes it worth examining honestly: You can be grateful for your life AND regret how you lived it. You can love your partner AND acknowledge you chose them partially because they fit the life plan you’d inherited. You can value your children AND recognize they were partly a checkbox on someone else’s timeline. You can appreciate your accomplishments AND feel the weight of doing them for applause instead of meaning.

This isn’t about self-pity or late-stage regret spirals. It’s about clarity—which is painful precisely because you finally have enough perspective to see what you couldn’t see before.

The psychology of midlife transitions suggests that this period of reckoning, while uncomfortable, can be generative.

Studies on midlife adults show that those who acknowledge and work through feelings of disconnection often move toward more authentic choices in their remaining decades

. It’s not wasted time, exactly. It’s just time that was spent in a particular way—and now you get to decide if that’s how you want to spend the rest of it.

Just launched: Laughing in the Face of Chaos by Rudá Iandê

Exhausted from trying to hold it all together? You show up. You smile. You say the right things. But under the surface, something’s tightening. Maybe you don’t want to “stay positive” anymore. Maybe you’re done pretending everything’s fine.

This book is your permission slip to stop performing. To understand chaos at its root and all of your emotional layers.

Laughing in the Face of Chaos

, Brazilian shaman Rudá Iandê brings over 30 years of deep, one-on-one work helping people untangle from the roles they’ve been stuck in—so they can return to something real. He exposes the quiet pressure to be good, be successful, be spiritual—and shows how freedom often lives on the other side of that pressure.

This isn’t a book about becoming your best self.

It’s about becoming your

Explore the book here

What changes when you finally stop pretending

Some people in their 40s I’ve known have started making different choices. They leave jobs that looked good but felt wrong. They end relationships they thought were supposed to work. They pick up hobbies their 22-year-old self wanted but their adult self deemed impractical. They say no to things they’ve always said yes to, just to see what happens.

Interestingly, they don’t always become happier. Sometimes they become lonelier—

the kind of loneliness that comes with choosing yourself over the comfort of familiar structures

. But there’s a difference between loneliness and disconnection. One can hurt. The other can hollow you out from the inside.

What these people gain isn’t uncomplicated happiness. It’s honesty. It’s the relief of stopping the performance. It’s building a life that actually fits, even if that life is smaller or stranger or less impressive than the one everyone expected.

The part no one warns you about

What surprised me most while researching this—what surprised everyone I talked to—was how much shame surrounds this regret. People don’t want to admit they spent two decades becoming the wrong person. It contradicts the narrative we’re taught, which is that if you work hard and follow the rules, it all works out.

The rules did work out, in a way. The problem is they weren’t your rules.

I think about what it would have meant if at 22, someone had told me: You are allowed to want different things than what your family expects. You are allowed to change your mind. You are allowed to be the kind of person that doesn’t fit neatly into anyone else’s life plan, including people you love. The happiness you build by conforming is a specific kind of happiness—it’s the happiness of being approved of, of fitting in, of doing it right. But there’s another kind, and you don’t get to try both simultaneously.

That wouldn’t have changed everything. I still would have made some of the same choices, probably, because they were good ones even if they weren’t mine originally. But I might have moved through them with more awareness, making them more consciously rather than sleepwalking into someone else’s ideal life.

What you can actually do with this information

If you’re in your 40s and recognizing this pattern in your own life, the regret is real and it’s worth sitting with for a while. Don’t rush past it into self-help mode. The point isn’t to feel bad about the past but to change the future—and you still have most of it ahead of you.

If you’re younger and reading this and something in it makes you uncomfortable—that’s good. That discomfort is useful. It’s telling you something about the ways you might be compromising yourself without fully realizing it.

Research on authentic connection and well-being suggests that people who stay true to their own values tend to build richer lives

—sometimes lonelier ones, sometimes more full, but always more honest ones.

The hardest part of getting to 40 and facing this particular regret is accepting that you can’t get that time back. You can only change what comes next. You can ask yourself what you actually want, separate from the chorus of voices that have been writing the script. You can start making choices based on your own internal compass instead of external validation. You can become someone you recognize in the mirror again.

It’s not too late. But it also requires admitting it was late—that you spent time becoming someone else’s idea of happy when you could have been building your own.

That’s the regret no one talks about, the one people whisper about in coffee shops when they finally feel safe enough to be honest. And it’s worth talking about—not as judgment, but as permission. Permission to stop performing. Permission to want something different. Permission to take the rest of your life seriously as yours.