After seven decades of chasing happiness at life's supposed highlights, I discovered it had been quietly living in my ordinary Thursdays all along, wearing sweatpants and drinking coffee while I searched for it in a wedding dress.
Add VegOut to your Google News feed. 
Last week, I sat in my garden watching the sun filter through the maple leaves, and it hit me like a thunderbolt: the happiest I've ever been had nothing to do with any of the moments I was supposed to treasure most. My wedding day? I spent it worried about the caterer who showed up late. The day we moved into our first house? I couldn't sleep for weeks, terrified we'd made a terrible financial mistake. My children's graduations? I smiled through them while my stomach churned with anxiety about their futures.
It's taken me seven decades to understand that happiness has been playing hide and seek with me all along, tucking itself into ordinary Wednesday afternoons and random conversations at the grocery store while I was busy looking for it at milestone events.
The weight of supposed-to-be moments
Have you ever noticed how heavy expectation feels? It sits on your chest like a stone, especially during those moments when everyone tells you that you should be glowing with joy. I remember standing in my wedding dress, hands trembling as I held the bouquet, thinking something must be wrong with me because instead of pure bliss, I felt like I might throw up. My mind raced through a thousand what-ifs while everyone kept telling me it was the happiest day of my life.
The pressure to feel a certain way at certain times is perhaps one of the cruelest tricks we play on ourselves. When my first child was born, I expected to feel an immediate, overwhelming rush of love. Instead, I felt terror. Pure, unadulterated terror that I was now responsible for this tiny, fragile human. The love came, of course, fierce and protective, but it arrived quietly over time, not in that dramatic hospital room moment I'd been promised by every movie and book I'd consumed.
These landmark occasions came wrapped in ribbons of anxiety because they mattered so much. Or rather, I believed they were supposed to matter so much. The weight of getting them "right" crushed any possibility of simply experiencing them. I was so busy directing the scene in my head, making sure everything looked perfect, that I forgot to actually live it.
When happiness sneaks in through the back door
Virginia Woolf once wrote about "moments of being," those instances when life suddenly comes into sharp focus. Mine have never announced themselves. They've slipped in while I was distracted, thinking about tomorrow's lesson plans or what to make for dinner.
Like the afternoon I was grading papers at my kitchen table, and my teenage son, usually monosyllabic and distant, suddenly started talking about a book he was reading. We ended up discussing Thoreau for two hours, his eyes bright with discovery. I didn't recognize the perfection of that moment until years later when he called from college to tell me he'd declared himself an English major.
Or the morning I woke at 5:30 as usual, made my tea, and sat with my journal. Nothing special planned, just another Thursday. But the light was doing something magical to the dust motes in the air, and the house was so peacefully quiet, and I found myself writing about my grandmother's hands. That simple morning stays with me more vividly than my entire graduation ceremony from college.
Recently, I discovered my mother's old recipe box tucked away in the basement. As I flipped through her handwritten cards, stained with vanilla and decades of use, I realized that her happiest moments probably looked a lot like mine: unplanned, unPhotographed, unrecognized until much later.
The anxiety of anticipation versus the surprise of joy
Why do the big moments bring anxiety instead of joy? I've thought about this endlessly, especially now that I have the luxury of time and distance to examine my life like an interesting specimen.
Part of it, I think, is that we can see the milestones coming from miles away. We have months, sometimes years, to build them up in our minds. We plan, we worry, we imagine every possible scenario. By the time the actual event arrives, we've already lived it a hundred times in our heads, each imaginary version more perfect than what reality could ever deliver.
But those unexpected moments of happiness? They catch us with our guard down. We're not trying to feel anything in particular, so joy can slip right in without having to compete with expectation.
During my 32 years of teaching, I learned that teenagers understand this instinctively. They know that the best parties are the impromptu ones, that planned fun rarely works. We adults forget this wisdom, scheduling our happiness like dental appointments.
Learning to recognize happiness in real-time
Here's what I wish I could tell my younger self: stop waiting for happiness to arrive at the appointed time. It's already there, probably sitting next to you on the couch right now, disguised as an ordinary evening.
These days, I try to catch happiness in the act. When I notice a moment of contentment, even a small one, I pause and acknowledge it. "Oh, hello," I say to it. "There you are." This morning, it was the particular way my coffee tasted, exactly right. Yesterday, it was a text from an old student telling me she'd become a teacher. These tiny recognitions don't make the moments bigger or more important, but they help me see that happiness has been faithful all along, showing up daily in her everyday clothes.
The big occasions still make me anxious. At 70, I've accepted that this is just how I'm wired. But now I know not to look for my deepest joy there. Instead, I find it in the unscheduled spaces between the milestones, in the moments that don't make it into photo albums or Facebook posts.
Final thoughts
If you're reading this and feeling anxious about an upcoming "should-be-happy" event, please know you're not broken or ungrateful. You're just human, trying to live up to impossible expectations. The real happiness is probably already in your life, wearing sweatpants and hiding in plain sight. It might be in your morning routine, in a conversation you'll have next week without planning it, or in a quiet moment that won't seem special until you look back on it years from now. The trick isn't to plan for happiness or to recognize it immediately. The trick is to trust that it's there, weaving itself through your ordinary days, waiting patiently for you to notice.
What’s Your Plant-Powered Archetype?
Ever wonder what your everyday habits say about your deeper purpose—and how they ripple out to impact the planet?
This 90-second quiz reveals the plant-powered role you’re here to play, and the tiny shift that makes it even more powerful.
12 fun questions. Instant results. Surprisingly accurate.
