Go to the main content

7 assumptions about retirement that collapse the moment you actually stop working

The retirement party ends, you clean out your desk, and suddenly discover that everything you believed about life after work—from friendships to finances to your own identity—was beautifully, devastatingly wrong.

Lifestyle

The retirement party ends, you clean out your desk, and suddenly discover that everything you believed about life after work—from friendships to finances to your own identity—was beautifully, devastatingly wrong.

Add VegOut to your Google News feed.

Last month, I found myself crying in the produce aisle at Whole Foods. Not because of the price of organic strawberries (though that's worth a few tears), but because a former colleague walked by without recognizing me. Two years into retirement, and I'd somehow become invisible. That moment shattered one of many assumptions I'd carried about what life after work would look like.

After 32 years of teaching high school English, I thought I knew exactly what retirement would bring. Turns out, I was spectacularly wrong about almost everything. The reality of stopping work is nothing like the glossy brochure version we've been sold, and I suspect many of you are discovering the same truth.

1) You'll finally have time for everything

Remember that endless list of projects you were saving for retirement? The garage that needs organizing, the novel you'd write, the languages you'd learn? I had convinced myself that time would suddenly expand like a magical accordion once I stopped working.

What actually happens is far stranger. Without the structure of work, time becomes slippery. Days blur together. You wake up on Tuesday thinking it's Saturday. Somehow, you're busier than ever while accomplishing less. The freedom to do anything often translates into doing nothing with any real intention.

I spent my first three months of retirement wandering around my house, starting projects and abandoning them halfway through. The Japanese class I enrolled in? Dropped it after two weeks. Not because I didn't have time, but because having all the time in the world made everything feel less urgent, less important.

2) Your work friends will stay close

For three decades, my teacher friends were my tribe. We survived budget cuts together, mourned difficult students, celebrated small victories in the faculty lounge. I was certain these bonds would transcend the workplace.

The truth stings: most work friendships are situational. Without the daily dramas of school life to bind us, conversations grew stilted. "How's retirement?" they'd ask, and I'd struggle to explain my new reality to people still deep in lesson plans and parent conferences. One by one, the lunch dates petered out. The group texts went silent.

This isn't anyone's fault. It's just that shared experiences create connection, and when the experiences stop being shared, the connections often fade. The friends who remain are precious, but they're fewer than you'd expect.

3) You'll know exactly who you are

At 64, surely you know yourself, right? Wrong. I discovered that much of who I thought I was existed only in relation to my job. Without "Ms. M the English teacher," I felt untethered, like a sentence without a subject.

Who was I at dinner parties when people asked what I did? The word "retired" felt like admitting defeat. I'd stumble through explanations, watching eyes glaze over as I described my new routine of journaling and afternoon walks. The identity crisis hit harder than any teenager's existential angst I'd witnessed in my classroom.

4) Money worries will disappear

Even with a decent pension and careful planning, financial anxiety doesn't vanish at retirement. It transforms. Instead of worrying about earning money, you worry about preserving it. Every expense feels like you're eating into a finite resource that must last an unknowable number of years.

I catch myself doing mental math at the grocery store in ways I never did when a paycheck was coming. Will this money last if I live to 95? What if I need long-term care? The security I expected feels more like walking a tightrope without a net below.

Having raised two children alone on a teacher's salary, I know how to stretch a dollar. But this is different. There's no next raise coming, no opportunity for overtime. The financial runway is fixed, and that changes everything about how you think about money.

5) Your health will magically improve

Without work stress, your body will thrive, right? I believed my aching knees (the reason I retired early) would improve once I stopped standing all day. That chronic exhaustion would lift like morning fog.

Instead, new aches appeared. Without the forced movement of teaching, I grew stiffer. The mental stimulation of managing 150 teenagers kept my mind sharp in ways I didn't appreciate. Now, I sometimes struggle to remember why I walked into a room. The structure of work, it turns out, provided a kind of physical and mental exercise I'd taken for granted.

Yes, I sleep better without the 5:30 AM alarm for school. But retirement isn't a magic cure for aging. Your body keeps its own schedule, regardless of your employment status.

6) You and your spouse will love all this togetherness

If you're married, you've probably imagined leisurely breakfasts together, spontaneous day trips, rediscovering each other without work's demands. The reality can be more complicated.

Suddenly, you're both home all day, every day. Those little habits that were charming in small doses become irritating in large ones. You discover that parallel lives worked better than you realized. The negotiations over space, time, and activities can rival any international peace talks.

It's not that love diminishes, but the relationship needs renegotiating. You're essentially learning to live with someone new, even if you've been married for decades. As I wrote in a previous post about navigating life transitions, every major change requires us to reimagine our closest relationships.

7) You'll naturally find new purpose

Perhaps the biggest myth is that purpose will organically emerge once you have time to pursue it. That volunteer work will fill the void, or grandchildren will become your new career.

Purpose, I've learned, doesn't just appear. It must be actively cultivated. At 66, I started writing because a friend pushed me to share my stories. But even that came after two years of feeling adrift, wondering what I was supposed to do with myself.

Recently, I discovered Jeanette Brown's new course "Your Retirement Your Way," and wished desperately I'd had this resource when I first retired. The course reminded me that retirement isn't an ending but a beginning for reinvention. Jeanette's guidance helped me see that my uncertainty wasn't weakness but wisdom, containing valuable information about what I truly wanted.

Final thoughts

These shattered assumptions aren't failures; they're invitations to create something more authentic than the retirement fantasy we've been sold. Every morning now, I wake naturally and spend an hour with my tea and journal, not because it's what retired people should do, but because it's what I need.

The truth about retirement is messier, harder, and ultimately more interesting than any assumption we bring to it. And maybe that's exactly as it should be.

Marlene Martin

Marlene is a retired high school English teacher and longtime writer who draws on decades of lived experience to explore personal development, relationships, resilience, and finding purpose in life’s second act. When she’s not at her laptop, she’s usually in the garden at dawn, baking Sunday bread, taking watercolor classes, playing piano, or volunteering at a local women’s shelter teaching life skills.

More Articles by Marlene

More From Vegout