After decades of dreaming about retirement's endless possibilities, we've discovered that having all the time in the world somehow means doing nothing with it—and the British mystery series we're debating feels like the most important decision we'll make all week.
Last week, I found myself standing in my kitchen at 3 PM, still in my pajamas, watching my husband reorganize the spice rack for the third time this month.
We'd spent the morning discussing whether to watch the nature documentary or the British mystery series, as if this was the most pressing decision of our lives. The afternoon stretched ahead like an empty highway, and I couldn't help but think about how thirty years ago, we'd sit across from each other at dinner, exhausted from work, dreaming about all the things we'd do when we finally had time.
Travel to Tuscany. Learn to paint. Take long walks without checking our watches. Build that greenhouse. Read all those books stacked on our nightstands.
Now we have nothing but time, and somehow we've become experts at filling it with nothing at all.
The retirement we imagined versus the one we're living
When you're forty-five and buried under deadlines, retirement looks like freedom incarnate. You picture yourself finally pursuing all those interests you've been postponing. You imagine mornings that begin with purpose instead of alarm clocks, days filled with meaningful activities you actually chose. My husband and I would lie in bed on Sunday mornings, cataloging our future adventures. We'd learn new languages, volunteer at the literacy center, maybe even take up ballroom dancing.
But here's what nobody tells you about retirement: without the structure of work, days can dissolve into each other like watercolors in rain. You wake up without an agenda, and somehow that feels more overwhelming than liberating. The freedom you craved becomes a kind of vertigo. What seemed like endless possibility from the vantage point of a busy career now feels like standing at the edge of a vast, featureless plain, unsure which direction to walk.
I remember the first month after I took early retirement at 64, when my knees couldn't handle standing in front of a classroom anymore. I'd wake up at my usual 5:30 AM, make coffee, and then sit at the kitchen table wondering what to do with myself. Teaching had been my identity for so long that without it, I felt like a ghost haunting my own life. My husband was still working then, and I'd find myself counting the hours until he came home, just to have someone to talk to about something other than what the cat did.
Why planning for retirement isn't the same as living it
Have you ever noticed how we prepare financially for retirement but rarely emotionally? We calculate our 401ks, plan our budgets, maybe even decide where we'll live. But we don't really prepare for the psychological shift of going from being needed and busy to having endless unstructured time.
The truth is, my husband and I had done everything right on paper. We'd saved diligently, paid off the mortgage, even made lists of our retirement goals. But lists aren't life. When you're working, leisure is precious because it's scarce. When every day is leisure, it loses its shine. It's like eating dessert for every meal; eventually, you crave vegetables.
What we hadn't anticipated was the loss of automatic purpose. Work, for all its stresses, provides a framework. It tells you when to get up, where to go, what to accomplish. It gives you stories to tell at dinner, problems to solve, a reason to buy new clothes. Without it, you have to become your own architect of meaning, and that's harder than any job I've ever had.
Breaking free from the comfortable numbness
Virginia Woolf once wrote that "the mind of man is capable of anything." I think about that quote often when I catch myself scrolling through channels, not really looking for something to watch, just looking. The mind that once juggled lesson plans and student needs, that analyzed literature and crafted arguments, now debates whether to have lunch at noon or 12:30.
The comfortable numbness of routine is seductive. Watch the morning news, second cup of coffee, maybe a walk if the weather's nice, lunch, afternoon TV, dinner, evening TV, bed. Repeat. It requires no effort, no vulnerability, no risk of failure. But it also offers no growth, no surprise, no stories worth telling.
I started learning Italian at 66, not because I had some grand plan, but because I was tired of my own excuses. Every day I'd been saying "tomorrow" to the trip to Italy I'd dreamed about. One morning, I simply signed up for an online class before I could talk myself out of it. Those first lessons were humbling. My brain, so used to being the teacher, struggled to be the student. But struggling felt better than stagnating.
Small rebellions against the predictable
The thing about breaking patterns is that you don't need to revolutionize your entire life. You just need to interrupt the autopilot. Last month, instead of turning on the TV after dinner, my husband and I sat on the back porch and played cards by candlelight. It wasn't profound, but it was different, and different was enough to remind us that we still had choices.
We've started what we call "surprise Tuesdays." Every Tuesday, one of us plans something, anything, that isn't watching TV. Last week, he drove us to a park we'd never visited and we fed the ducks. The week before, I signed us up for a library lecture on local history. Were these earth-shattering experiences? No. But they were experiences, not just time passing.
What I've learned from downsizing our home is that experiences matter infinitely more than possessions. The weekend getaway where I accidentally outbid my future husband at a school auction became a story we still tell. The ceramic bowl gathering dust doesn't. Yet somehow, in retirement, we'd been choosing the equivalent of dust-gathering over story-making, day after day.
Final thoughts
If you're in this chapter too, the one you talked about for decades, and you're wondering if this is all there is, know that you're not alone in asking that question. The answer isn't in some dramatic life overhaul or expensive adventure. It's in the decision to turn off the TV tonight and do literally anything else. Take a drive with no destination. Call an old friend. Try a new recipe that might fail spectacularly. Sign up for that class, start that project, have that conversation you've been avoiding.
This chapter doesn't have to be about watching life from the couch. It can be about finally having the time to be curious again, to be bad at something new, to surprise yourself. The remote control is optional. The choice, every single day, is yours.
What’s Your Plant-Powered Archetype?
Ever wonder what your everyday habits say about your deeper purpose—and how they ripple out to impact the planet?
This 90-second quiz reveals the plant-powered role you’re here to play, and the tiny shift that makes it even more powerful.
12 fun questions. Instant results. Surprisingly accurate.
