Some plant-based swaps are total flops, but I've cracked the code on what actually delivers.
Look, I've been vegan long enough to know that not every alternative is created equal. Some are genuinely amazing. Others taste like cardboard had a baby with disappointment.
I'm not here to trash products just for fun. But after years of trying everything, I've learned which swaps are worth it and which ones send me straight back to the kitchen to make something better. Here's what consistently lets me down and the homemade versions that actually work.
1. Store-bought vegan parmesan
The stuff in the green shaker? It's basically nutritional yeast with trust issues. Most brands taste like salty dust, and the texture is all wrong. It sits on top of your pasta like sad confetti instead of melting into anything.
What I make instead: I blend raw cashews, nutritional yeast, garlic powder, and salt in a food processor until it's finely ground. Takes two minutes. The cashews add richness that makes it taste like actual cheese, and it sticks to pasta instead of rolling off. I keep a jar in the fridge and it lasts weeks.
2. Coconut bacon
I wanted to love this so badly. Coconut flakes, smoked and seasoned, should theoretically work. But they always end up either soggy or weirdly sweet, and the texture is more like eating flavored paper than anything bacon-adjacent.
What I make instead: Rice paper bacon. Cut rice paper sheets into strips, brush with a mix of soy sauce, liquid smoke, maple syrup, and smoked paprika, then bake until crispy.
The texture is actually crispy and shattery like real bacon. It holds up on a BLT and doesn't taste like you're eating a macaroon on your sandwich.
3. Vegan butter for baking
Most vegan butters are fine for spreading on toast. But baking? That's where things fall apart. Literally. Cookies spread too much, pie crusts get weird and greasy, and nothing browns properly. The water content is usually too high and the fat composition is off.
What I make instead: I use refined coconut oil for most baking. It's solid at room temperature like butter, has a similar fat content, and actually creates flaky layers in pastry.
For cookies, I do half coconut oil and half vegan butter to get the right spread and texture. Game changer for chocolate chip cookies especially.
4. Chickpea water meringue
Aquafaba was supposed to be the miracle ingredient. And sure, it whips up into peaks. But those peaks are fragile, weepy, and taste faintly of beans no matter how much vanilla you add. Meringue cookies never get truly crispy, and they deflate if you look at them wrong.
What I make instead: I just skip meringue entirely and make coconut whipped cream when I need something light and fluffy. Full-fat coconut cream, chilled overnight, whips up beautifully and actually tastes good. It's not meringue, but it fills the same role on pies and desserts without the disappointment factor.
5. Nutritional yeast as a cheese sauce base
Nutritional yeast is great as a topping. But those recipes that claim you can just blend it with cashews and water for cheese sauce? They're lying to you. It tastes like vitamin-fortified sadness. The flavor is too sharp and yeasty, never creamy or rich.
What I make instead: I still use cashews, but I add white miso paste, a little tahini, and roasted garlic. The miso adds that funky, aged cheese flavor that nutritional yeast tries and fails to deliver.
Tahini makes it creamy without being gritty. I use just a tablespoon of nutritional yeast for color, not flavor.
6. Egg replacer powder in scrambles
Those black salt and chickpea flour scrambles everyone raves about? They're gritty, they smell like sulfur, and the texture is closer to wet sand than eggs. I've tried every ratio and technique. They're just not it.
What I make instead: Firm tofu, crumbled and cooked with turmeric, nutritional yeast, and a splash of plant milk. The key is getting the pan really hot first and not stirring too much. Let it develop some color. Add vegetables, hot sauce, whatever.
It's not trying to be eggs, it's just a really good savory breakfast that fills the same role.
7. Vegan cheese slices for grilled cheese
Most vegan cheese slices either don't melt at all or they melt into a weird, plasticky layer that separates from the bread. The flavor is usually aggressively processed-tasting. Even the fancy brands often disappoint when you actually try to cook with them.
What I make instead: I make a quick cheese sauce with cashews, miso, and tapioca starch. The tapioca starch is the secret. It makes the sauce stretchy and gooey when heated. I spread it thick on bread before grilling, and it creates that melty, pull-apart situation you actually want. Takes five minutes to blend up a batch.
Final thoughts
Here's the thing about vegan alternatives: the best ones usually aren't trying to be exact replicas.
They're doing their own thing that happens to fill the same role. Store-bought options are getting better, but sometimes the DIY version just works better for your taste and your budget.
I'm not saying never buy convenience products. I absolutely do. But when something consistently disappoints me, I'd rather spend ten minutes making something I'll actually enjoy. Your kitchen time is worth more than choking down something mediocre just because it's plant-based.
What’s Your Plant-Powered Archetype?
Ever wonder what your everyday habits say about your deeper purpose—and how they ripple out to impact the planet?
This 90-second quiz reveals the plant-powered role you’re here to play, and the tiny shift that makes it even more powerful.
12 fun questions. Instant results. Surprisingly accurate.
