A survey of US medical schools run from August 2008 through July 2009 found that medical students received an average of 19.6 required contact hours of nutrition instruction across their medical school careers. The reported range ran from 0 to 70 hours.
The figures come from Adams, Kohlmeier and Zeisel, whose paper appeared in Academic Medicine in September 2010 and is indexed on PubMed as PMID 20736683.
The survey went to all 127 accredited US medical schools that were matriculating students at the time. Respondents from 109 of them, or 86 per cent, completed some part of it.
The video below, "Your Doctor Studied Almost No Nutrition", makes the claim about how little nutrition doctors study. The survey is where the published numbers come from.
How the survey worked
The two-page online survey was devised by the Nutrition in Medicine Project at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. Its stated purpose was to quantify required nutrition hours and the types of courses in which the instruction was offered, and to compare the results with previous surveys.
The authors asked their contacts, "most of whom were nutrition educators", to report the nutrition contact hours required for their medical students.
They also asked whether those hours occurred in a designated nutrition course, within another course, or during clinical rotations. The question was about required teaching rather than everything a school offered.
Of the 109 schools that responded, 103 required some form of nutrition education, which leaves six that did not. A smaller group, 105 schools, answered the questions on courses and contact hours, and those 105 are the basis of the headline figures.
That also leaves 18 of the 127 schools contacted that did not complete any part of the survey. The numbers describe the schools that replied, not the full set of accredited institutions.
The 25 hour benchmark
The comparison point is a 1985 report from the National Academy of Sciences and the National Research Council, Nutrition Education in U.S. Medical Schools, published by National Academy Press. It set a minimum of 25 required hours.
Of the 105 schools answering on courses and contact hours, 28, or 27 per cent, met that minimum. Only 26 of the 105, or 25 per cent, required a dedicated nutrition course.
That leaves roughly three quarters of the responding schools below a figure that was already more than two decades old when the survey ran.
The paper also sets the results against a 2004 survey. The average then was 22.3 hours, compared with 19.6 in 2008 to 2009.
In 2004, 40 of 104 schools, or 38 per cent, met the 25 hour minimum. By the later survey that had fallen to 28 of 105, or 27 per cent.
Dedicated courses moved the same way. In 2004, 32 of 106 schools, or 30 per cent, required one. In the later round it was 26 of 105, or 25 per cent.
The denominators differ slightly between rounds. The 2004 comparison on the minimum uses 104 schools and the one on dedicated courses uses 106, against 105 in the later round.
On all three measures, average hours, schools meeting the minimum and schools with a dedicated course, the later numbers were lower than the 2004 ones.
The authors' conclusion ran to one sentence: "The amount of nutrition education that medical students receive continues to be inadequate."
What the 19.6 figure does not say
The 19.6 hours is an average across the schools that answered. It is not a figure for any individual doctor, and no student can be assumed to have had exactly that amount.
The spread was wide. The reported range started at 0 hours and reached 70, more than three times the average.
The abstract gives overall figures and does not break the 19.6 hours down by year of study.
The figure is also not a 2026 number. The data were collected between August 2008 and July 2009 and published the following year.
The survey counted required contact hours, so teaching that students could choose to take sits outside the count. It recorded time and course type rather than what students learned.
The study covers US medical schools only. The abstract reports nothing about medical training in the UK or anywhere else.
Readers who want the authors' own wording can read the abstract on the PubMed record, which carries the purpose, method, results and conclusions as published. The paper appeared in volume 85, issue 9, pages 1537 to 1542.
Other benchmarks in nutrition science and clinical history include how the 0.8 g per kg protein RDA was set, Denis Burkitt's 1971 fibre paper and how Russell Wilder named the ketogenic diet in 1921.
Photo: A breakfast meal arranged according to the USDA MyPlate guide (illustrative stand-in). U.S. Department of Agriculture, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.




