What boomers call comfort food, younger generations often call questionable life choices served on a plate.
Every generation has its own signature flavors, comfort foods, and quirky kitchen experiments.
For boomers, many of these dishes come from a time when convenience foods were booming, recipes were shared through word of mouth, and creativity often meant combining whatever was in the pantry.
To them, these combinations are nostalgic classics that bring back memories of family dinners and simpler times.
To younger generations, though?
Some of these pairings range from mildly confusing to downright horrifying.
Here are eight food combos boomers love that tend to make younger people raise their eyebrows—and sometimes their stomachs.
1. Cottage cheese and canned peaches
Boomers see this as a refreshing, high-protein snack.
It was light, affordable, and easy to make back in the day.
But to younger people, the texture combination of creamy curds and syrupy canned fruit is… unsettling.
Many can’t wrap their heads around why something tangy and savory is topped with a super-sweet, slightly mushy peach half.
It’s the kind of dish that looks like it came straight out of a retro diet cookbook—and tastes just as questionable.
2. Bologna and mayonnaise sandwiches
For many boomers, this was a childhood lunchbox staple.
It was cheap, easy, and filling, which mattered a lot for big families on a budget.
But younger generations, who grew up with fresher sandwich options and a wider variety of ingredients, tend to find this combo bland and a little sad.
The thought of a thick slice of processed bologna slathered with plain mayo between white bread feels more like cafeteria punishment than comfort food today.
It’s nostalgia on a plate for some, and a culinary nightmare for others.
3. Jell-O salads with mystery ingredients
Few dishes are as emblematic of boomer-era cooking as the infamous Jell-O salad.
These technicolor creations often included fruit, marshmallows, nuts, or even shredded vegetables suspended in gelatin.
Some versions even featured mayo or sour cream stirred in for “creaminess.”
To younger generations, this combo feels like a science experiment gone wrong.
Why mix dessert, salad, and dairy in one wobbly dish?
Boomers, however, see it as festive and fun—a holiday table classic they genuinely look forward to every year.
4. Peanut butter and pickles
This pairing might seem like a pregnancy craving gone rogue, but many boomers swear by it.
The salty crunch of pickles against the creamy, nutty richness of peanut butter hits the spot for them.
Younger people, though, tend to recoil at the thought.
For a generation raised on peanut butter paired exclusively with sweet things like jelly or bananas, this savory twist feels deeply wrong.
Still, there are a few adventurous millennials and Gen Zers who have admitted—reluctantly—that it’s weirdly addictive once you get past the initial shock.
5. Tuna noodle casserole with crushed chips on top
This dish was a weeknight hero for boomer households.
It was cheap, filling, and used pantry staples like canned tuna, condensed cream of mushroom soup, and egg noodles.
The pièce de résistance? A crunchy topping of crushed potato chips or buttered breadcrumbs.
To younger generations, this combo of heavy carbs, canned fish, and salty chips feels like a relic of a time when convenience mattered more than balance.
It’s comfort food to boomers, but to modern eaters, it’s a calorie bomb they’re not sure they want to detonate.
6. Hot dogs and baked beans
For boomers, this was an iconic cookout or weeknight dinner pairing.
Sweet, smoky baked beans alongside savory hot dogs felt like a perfect match back then.
But today’s younger crowd, with its emphasis on fresh ingredients and plant-based options, often finds the combo a bit too heavy—and the presentation less than appealing.
It’s also a dish that doesn’t age well when reheated, which makes leftovers particularly unappealing.
Still, for many boomers, this meal tastes like summer evenings and backyard memories.
7. Mayonnaise in everything
To boomers, mayo isn’t just a condiment—it’s a food group.
From pasta salads to dips to casseroles, mayonnaise was the secret ingredient in countless recipes of the past.
Younger generations, who tend to favor lighter dressings and fresher flavors, often find the sheer volume of mayo overwhelming.
The idea of adding giant spoonfuls to everything from sandwiches to “salads” made entirely of starch feels heavy and outdated.
For boomers, though, it’s the creamy glue that holds many of their favorite dishes together.
8. Spam and eggs
Spam was a pantry staple for many boomer families, especially during times when fresh meat was expensive or hard to find.
Fried up alongside eggs, it made a hearty breakfast or quick dinner.
Today, Spam has a cult following in certain cuisines, but for most younger people, the idea of eating mystery meat from a can is hard to stomach.
The salty, processed flavor combined with runny eggs feels like a clash of textures and tastes.
Yet for boomers, it’s pure nostalgia on a plate—a reminder of simpler times and family meals around the kitchen table.
The bigger picture
These bizarre food combos might make younger generations cringe, but they tell a bigger story.
They reflect the values and circumstances of the time: frugality, convenience, and creativity with limited ingredients.
What seems strange now was often born out of necessity back then.
Boomers hold onto these dishes not just for the taste, but for the memories they carry.
And while younger people may never fully embrace peanut butter and pickles or Jell-O salads, they can appreciate the history behind them.
What’s Your Plant-Powered Archetype?
Ever wonder what your everyday habits say about your deeper purpose—and how they ripple out to impact the planet?
This 90-second quiz reveals the plant-powered role you’re here to play, and the tiny shift that makes it even more powerful.
12 fun questions. Instant results. Surprisingly accurate.
