VegOut

Eat Better Live Lighter
Magazine Recipes
About Masthead Editorial Newsletter

Okinawans ate about 50% more green and yellow vegetables than the national average in 1988, and by 1998 that gap was gone while daily meat intake passed 100 grams

A 2003 paper tracked Okinawan diets from 1988 to 1998, when the prefecture's lead in green and yellow vegetables and pulses fell to the national average.

·NOVEMBER 19, 2026·3 MIN READ

Photo: goya champuru, an Okinawan stir-fry. pelican from Tokyo, Japan / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0. Share-alike licence.

In 1988, daily intake of green and yellow vegetables in Okinawa was about 50 per cent higher than the Japanese national average. Ten years later that lead had gone, and daily meat intake in the prefecture had passed 100 grams. The figures come from a 2003 paper by Miyagi, Iwama, Kawabata and Hasegawa in the Asia Pacific Journal of Public Health. The lead author, S Miyagi, was in health administration at Kagawa Nutrition University.

The study asked two questions: why the longevity indices in Okinawa were once the highest in Japan, and what lay behind their recent decline. Okinawa was Japan's poorest prefecture, and Japan had the longest life expectancy at birth in the world. At the time of writing, the latest life expectancy at birth for men in Okinawa was no higher than the national average.

What the 1988 numbers said

The measure is daily intake in grams, set against the national average, not rankings or shopping baskets. As of 1988, daily intake of meat and daily intake of pulses in Okinawa were both approximately 90 grams, about 20 per cent and about 30 per cent higher than the national average respectively. Daily intake of green and yellow vegetables was about 50 per cent higher than the national average.

That is a particular combination: more meat than the rest of Japan, and more pulses and more green and yellow vegetables as well. The abstract gives a gram figure for meat and pulses but only a percentage gap for the vegetables, so the vegetable total itself is not stated.

The comparison cuts across the usual shorthand, which treats the Okinawan pattern as simply plant-heavy. On these numbers the prefecture sat above the national average on the animal side and the plant side at once.

Ten years later, the gap closed

By 1998, three measures had moved together. Daily meat intake had surpassed 100 grams. The fat energy ratio had surpassed 30 per cent. Daily intake of pulses and of green and yellow vegetables had declined to the level of the national average.

The plant-side advantage did not merely shrink. It went, on both the pulses measure and the green and yellow vegetables measure, while the meat figure kept rising. Ten years is a short window for a whole prefecture's intake to converge on the national mean.

The authors also recorded a change in what younger people were choosing. Young Japanese, and young men in Okinawa in particular, had shown a tendency to avoid the traditional dishes of stewed meat and champuru. The abstract does not quantify that shift.

What the paper sets alongside the diet figures

The authors put the intake data next to mortality data. In 1990, the age-adjusted death rates of the three leading causes of death in Okinawa were lower than their national averages. By 2000, the standard mortality ratios for heart disease and cerebrovascular disease for both sexes in Okinawa had increased compared with their 1990 levels.

The detail runs as follows. The age-adjusted death rates of ischaemic heart disease and of cerebrovascular disease for men rose to 45.5 and 63.5 in 2000, up from 42.9 and 59.1 in 1990. The standard mortality ratio of ischaemic heart disease for men in Okinawa reached 101 in 2000, on a scale where Japan equals 100. The national ranking of Okinawa prefecture for life expectancy at birth for men dropped.

The abstract does not establish that the dietary change caused that decline. It sets the two trends side by side across the same decade and asks why the longevity indices fell. Income, smoking, physical activity, medical care and the age structure of the prefecture are not settled by these figures.

The other limit is the date. This is a 2003 paper describing intakes recorded in 1988 and 1998 and mortality recorded in 1990 and 2000. It is a record of that decade, not a description of what Okinawans eat now.

Other diet-and-disease records are set out in Denis Burkitt's 1971 fibre paper and in how Russell Wilder named the ketogenic diet in 1921.