From tech anxiety to prioritizing emotion over innovation, here are 7 psychological reasons many Boomers steer clear of ChatGPT.
I’ve lost count of how many times a Baby-Boomer relative has asked, “So what is ChatGPT, exactly—and why should I trust it?”
Their tone is rarely hostile, more…cautious, the way you’d approach a self-driving car that just rolled into your driveway.
That caution isn’t random.
Decades of research on technology adoption — and on aging itself — suggest that older adults are guided by a predictable mix of motivations, concerns, and cognitive habits.
Below are 7 traits psychologists most often see in Boomers who sidestep tools like ChatGPT. As always, there are plenty of exceptions; treat this list as a lens, not a label.
1. Elevated technology anxiety
Long before artificial intelligence hit the headlines, researchers were documenting “technology anxiety”—the uneasy blend of fear and frustration some people feel when confronting new digital tools.
One frequently cited study of older adults aged 53–88 found that higher anxiety ratings predicted lower willingness to explore unfamiliar software, even when objective skills were adequate.
ChatGPT’s conversational interface can look deceptively simple, which perversely raises the stakes: if something goes wrong, users may feel it reflects on their competence, not the tool’s quirks. Couple that with headlines about “AI hallucinations,” and anxiety shifts from mild discomfort to outright avoidance.
2. Preference for tried-and-true routines
Habits offer cognitive savings: once a routine is locked in, the brain runs on autopilot and frees energy for other tasks. Because
Boomers have had decades longer to engrain routines (asking Google a specific way, calling a librarian for answers, flipping through manuals) and the cost of swapping them for ChatGPT feels higher.
Psychologists call this the status-quo bias — our tendency to prefer familiar defaults even when objectively better options exist.
Each additional year a workflow remains stable further cements that bias, making the learning curve of a new AI interface seem steeper than it really is.
When every minute of effort has an opportunity cost, maintaining the old system feels rational.
3. Lower perceived self-efficacy with AI
Self-efficacy — the belief that you can perform a task successfully — shapes whether you even attempt that task.
In surveys, older adults often report lower confidence about troubleshooting tech than younger users do.
The paradox: skill gaps are sometimes minor, but the belief gap is huge.
ChatGPT’s open-ended nature—“Ask me anything!”—can amplify that doubt.
Unlike an app with clear buttons, a prompt box offers no guardrails, so Boomers may fear “breaking” something by typing the wrong request.
Add in the absence of a physical manual and the intimidation factor doubles.
4. Heightened skepticism about data privacy
Boomers grew up before the era of mass data collection, so their baseline expectation of privacy is higher than that of younger cohorts. When they hear that anything typed into ChatGPT might train future models, alarm bells ring.
A 2023 Pew Research Center survey on data privacy reported that roughly three-quarters of U.S. adults are concerned about how companies use their personal information — evidence that broad wariness about corporate AI isn’t limited to any single age group.
Older adults have also witnessed a parade of high-profile data breaches, reinforcing the sense that “the safest data is the data you never give away.”
Until transparency around data use improves—or a trusted friend vouches for safety—many Boomers prefer to stay on the sidelines.
5. Focus on emotionally meaningful goals
Laura Carstensen’s socioemotional selectivity theory argues that as people age and perceive time as limited, they prioritize emotionally rich experiences over information gathering.
In Carstensen’s words, “As time horizons shrink, people become increasingly selective, investing greater resources in emotionally meaningful goals.”
For Boomers, tinkering with ChatGPT to draft a clever email may feel less valuable than phone-catching up with grandchildren or tending a garden — activities that deliver guaranteed emotional payoff.
Even if ChatGPT could save them time, the learning phase steals minutes from pursuits that already feel deeply satisfying.
6. Trust in human expertise over algorithms
Many Boomers were educated in an era when encyclopedias, librarians, and subject-matter experts reigned supreme.
That cultural script equates human credentials with reliability.
When an algorithm like ChatGPT claims authority but can’t cite traditional credentials — or sometimes “hallucinates” facts — Boomers’ trust instinct points them back to human pros.
The occasional botched AI answer spreads quickly through peer networks, cementing the narrative that “machines guess; humans know,” even if the sample size is small.
7. Fixed mindset about learning new tech
Carol Dweck’s mindset research shows that people who view abilities as fixed (“I’m just not a tech person”) are less likely to persevere through learning curves.
While a fixed mindset isn’t age-bound, it can crystallize over decades of tech changes that felt bewildering or irrelevant.
A single frustrating experience — say, a baffling smartphone update — may reinforce the belief that future tools (like ChatGPT) will be equally opaque.
Conversely, small wins can loosen that rigidity: a successful voice-to-text dictation or a seamless video-chat session can nudge Boomers toward seeing tech skills as learnable rather than innate.
Final thoughts
Avoiding ChatGPT doesn’t mean Boomers are anti-innovation; it often means their psychological cost-benefit math comes out negative.
Lower that cost — by offering patient demos, clarifying privacy safeguards, or tying ChatGPT to emotionally meaningful tasks — and curiosity can eclipse caution.
Once those first positive experiences accumulate, the same status-quo bias that kept them away can flip and keep them engaged.
Because at the end of the day, technology adoption isn’t about age — it’s about fit. Show someone how a tool fits their goals, routine, and comfort zone, and even the most reluctant adopters may surprise you.
What’s Your Plant-Powered Archetype?
Ever wonder what your everyday habits say about your deeper purpose—and how they ripple out to impact the planet?
This 90-second quiz reveals the plant-powered role you’re here to play, and the tiny shift that makes it even more powerful.
12 fun questions. Instant results. Surprisingly accurate.
